Showing posts with label Jewish law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jewish law. Show all posts

Wednesday, July 9, 2025

Chabad Rabbi Vigler On Law During A War

                                              Rabbi Dovid Vigler: Be grateful for what you have                            

  Nadene Goldfoot








Raised in South Africa and educated in some of the finest Yeshivas in Israel, England, New York, and Australia, Rabbi Dovid Vigler strives to share the beauty and depth of Judaism in a clear, conversational and down-to-earth manner.

I watched him today on youtube when he explained how Israel is still  most moral in fighting against Hamas.  The world at this time believes the opposite.  This war has never been fought like this before with the enemy hiding behind their own civilians including children.  He was on Alan Dershowitz's show.  Alan was also defending Israel and the uniqueness of this situation.  

Israel might have been stopped completely when this happened, but it is Hamas who has been attacking Israel since 2005 when Israel turned over Gaza to them free and clear in the very name of PEACE.  Since then, Israel has been attacked and Israelis have died.  Barzeliai Hospital near the Gazan border was attacked so much they had to move operations in the basement to operate.  This Jewish hospital served both Jews and Arabs.  

Following its victory in the 1967 Six-Day War, Israel captured and occupied the Gaza Strip from Egypt. For the next 38 years, Israel controlled the strip and established 21 Jewish settlements there. In 2005, under international and domestic pressure, Israel unilaterally withdrew its military forces and settlements from the Gaza Strip. This left the enclave to be governed by the Palestinian Authority. However, Israel continues to control Gaza's borders, airspace, coastline, and other essential services. 

So if this hiding business worked to the benefit of Hamas, Israel couldn't stop Hamas and everyone would have been killed in Israel.

Israel has the reputation of being the most moral of all armies in the world.  A colonel in England, Richard Kemp,  has commented about this.  Israel, instead, has gone after Hamas, especially since October 7, 2023 when Hamas held the worst surprise attack on Israel that will never be forgotten.  Israel is following a 4,000 year old law of War.

In our 4,000 year old Jewish law, a rodef (Hebrew: רודף, lit. "pursuer") refers to someone who is actively pursuing another person with the intent to murder or commit a serious sexual assault (like raping a man or a betrothed woman). In this case, it is a Hamas terrorist enemy.  
Based on the principle of din rodef ("law of the pursuer"), Jewish law allows any bystander to stop a rodef, even if it means killing them, to protect the intended victim. However, there are important conditions:
  • The rodef must be warned and given a chance to stop, if possible and time permits.
  • The bystander must use the least amount of force necessary to stop the rodef. If non-lethal means are sufficient, those must be employed before resorting to lethal force. 
  • IDF have followed all these important conditions with warnings of all kinds.  
Rabbi Vigler uses the example of a woman in labor and the baby is actually causing 
the death of the mother on all accounts.  There is no hope.  The doctor is going to 
save either the baby or the mother.  Which one is it to be?  The mother.  The baby is
doing the killing.  Of course, this would not happen today if one is in a hospital, we  
must believe.  There, they would be able to save both.  
Resource:
                                       

Thursday, February 20, 2025

The Jewish Goal: Saving Lives When Reality is Taking Lives and the Reason For It All

 Nadene Goldfoot                                                

One of the most basic principles in Jewish law is that human life comes first. Almost any religious commandment can be broken in order to save the life of a human being.  Pikuach Nefesh:  the Jewish value of saving a life.  

This is why it is so terribly hard for the Jewish soul to have to defend itself by taking a life.  This is why in their defensive fighting they have done everything humanely possible to tell their enemy's people to depart from the area of fire where war happens.  It's a fact known to others that Israel does this, but the battle with Hamas terrorism hides this well, and people think of us as those who take lives needlessly, instead.   

Jewish law is clear: if someone is trying to harm another you have a duty to stop the person attempting to murder another even if it means killing them

BUT if the person is innocent you may not kill someone innocent to save someone else.  

  • Imminent threat: The threat must be immediate and deadly, not a potential future danger.
  • No other option: All other means of escape or defense should be exhausted before resorting to lethal force.
  • Moral obligation: Jewish law views defending oneself against a deadly threat as a moral duty, not just a right. That's what our army is:  IDF (Israeli Defense Force).  

Golda Meir

“When peace comes we will perhaps in time be able to forgive the Arabs for killing our sons, but it will be harder for us to forgive them for having forced us to kill their sons. Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.”  Golda Meir was Prime Minister from 1969 to 1974 during the Six Day War.  She was born May 3, 1898, Kyiv, Ukraine, and managed to live in the USA many years as well from 1906 to 1921 when she immigrated with her husband to Israel.    

Why such hatred that causes one people to hate Jews?   I find it awesome that this is prophecized in the bible, a book most people pooh pooh these days as fairy tales.  Pregnant Jewish mothers are told to have happy thoughts, and not dwell in things they dislike.  It's not known if emotions are carried in genes or not.  We do know that babies can be conditioned from day one to have an attitude like their parents, though.                                       

               Israel according to Genesis 15:18-21

 Jews have always known that their place in this world is told in the bible itself which gives the size and locale of the land, and also says that it is for the children of Abraham. According to the Bible, the land promised to Abraham's descendants, often called the "Promised Land" or Canaan, stretched from the "River of Egypt" (generally considered the Nile) in the south to the Euphrates River in the north, encompassing a large area including modern-day Israel, the West Bank, Gaza, parts of Jordan, Lebanon, and Syriathis is described in Genesis 15:18 as a vast territory, not a precise boundary.  King David (1010 -970 BCE) established the Land of Israel, a teeny section of the land, and the 
Assyrians kidnapped 10 of the 12 tribes in 721 BCE and took them away.
    After WWI, the thought was that Palestine would become the Jewish Homeland.

  They were forced out by the Romans in 70 CE and hadn't been able to return until WWI, when they helped the Allies to win the war by fighting and creating a type of ammunition that was a winner.  The problem was that the Arabs also did the same thing, help the Brits fight in that war, too.  The Brits promised the same land to the 2 different people; descendants of Abraham.in the Bible,    

the Old Testament (Genesis 16:1–16; 17:18–26; 21:1–21), 

              Hagar and Ishmael told by Abraham to leave the compound

Isaac and Ishmael were brothers born to Abraham, but to different mothersIsaac was the son of Sarah, and Ishmael was the son of Hagar, handmaid of Sarah, probably from Egypt.   Ishmael was born and brought up in Abraham's household. Some 13 years later, however, Sarah conceived Isaac, with whom God established his covenant. Isaac became Abraham's sole heir, and Ishmael and Hagar were banished to the desert, though God promised that Ishmael would raise up a great nation of his own.

The Arabs most likely did not know of the biblical prophecy, but Mohammed tried to convert us into Muslims and failed when Jews lived in Medina, so soured on us.  We knew we had been practicing what Mohammed was trying to sell for the past thousand years, and saw no reason to try a new brand of their own religion.  The fact turned out to be a sword that spoke for the Arabs, and death was upon our ancestors.  They would not just turn away and try to sell their product to their own and other people, but killed whole tribes of Jews in Arabia which continued till the time of anti-Semitism in Europe took hold, and then it became a safe reserve for Jews.  Go figure!  Jews were then 2nd class citizens but kept their lives-at least most of the time. 
  
The Balfour Declaration was signed on November 2, 1917. It was a letter from the British Foreign Secretary, Arthur Balfour, to Lord Walter Rothschild, a leader of the Jewish community. Explanation:  The declaration promised to establish a Jewish national home in Palestine, which was then under Ottoman control. The British made this promise to gain Jewish support for their efforts in World War I.  
In 1920, the Arab population of Palestine was approximately 600,000The majority of the population was Arab, with the majority of those being Muslim.
In 1922, the British Mandate of Palestine conducted its first census, which recorded a population of 757,182.  This is ALL of PALESTINE!!                                                                                                   
                     Israeli Paratroopers seeing the Western Wall for first time
as Israelis were kept out of Jerusalem until 1967

Hamas terrorists, democratically voted in by the Palestinians thanks to Obama's suggestions,  ruled Gaza, land which Israel held in 1967 after the Six Day War, and turned around and gave to the Arabs for a peace initiative.  Five minutes later they were shooting at Israelis instead.  No peace;  No, NO, No.  They've been shooting ever since.  

Every offer Israel made to Hamas was turned down in favor of them taking ALL of Israel for themselves, wiping out the Jews.  That's still their goal in life.  

Europe, England, every other place is now blaming Israel for being aggressive and killing off Hamas.  All their lives, they have lived in an anti-Semitic environment, so that inclination comes easy.  How we have stuck to our guns behooves me, but somehow, we have.  We're still Jews;  not Christians or Muslims. We are known to be stubborn in that.   

What Trump is offering the Arabs, Israel had already done over and over,  and the reaction of their neighbors haven't changed either.  Instead, the UN has managed to help the population double over and over again.  Good luck, Trump.  You and the USA  are a known power-house in the world.  Perhaps, perhaps you will do it.  It's your chance to do a HUGE Mitzvah !  

Resource:

CBN News: Thursday 2/20/2025, interview of lady explaining Jewish view

https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/pikuach-nefesh-the-overriding-jewish-value-of-human-life/

https://www.britannica.com/biography/Ishmael-son-of-Abraham

Tuesday, August 1, 2023

SLAVERY: When Jews Kept Slaves, Part II

 Nadene Goldfoot                                           

  2nd Bout of Slavery:  Ancient Rome took Jews as slaves when they attacked Jerusalem in the year 70 even though Jews had lived in Rome since 139 BCE.    Jews were captured along with early Christians, put in animal circuses with the lions, slaves for people in Rome, put in army.  
          Did Moses learn about circumcision in Egypt where they evidently practiced it?  Was this a process of becoming a slave, proselytised into the culture of Egypt or showing Egyptian ownership?  

First we were slaves in Egypt for 400 years at least.  Civilization reached the point where these past slaves owned slaves, themselves.  What their culture said about any humane aspects of slavery probably has never reached the rest of the world, considering the reports we get about slavery from the United States.


Jewish law covered the institution of slavery which not only existed at the time of Moses (1391-1271 BCE) but on into our recent past of the 19th century, and may even be a part of some illegal goings on today. The Law made detailed provision for its humane regulation.

Scriptural Law allowed an Israelite to become another Israelite's slave only for a limited period with manumission at the 7th year of service or at the jubilee year;  the freed slave, moreover, was to receive a suitable parting gift.  

   Rebuilding the Temple during 70 years from Babylon 

Even this limited form of slavery became impossible after the Babylonian Exile that took place from 597 and 586 BCE to538 BCE., usually thought of as a period of 70 years. 

Solomon got into trouble by having his population work for free on the building of the Temple.  When he died in 920 BCE, the Israelis cut themselves in half with the Northern Tribes of Israel leaving Judah, the southern tribe where Jerusalem and the Temple was. Then each group had their own king, and plenty of fighting back and forth.  Treating his people as slaves was his worst idea.   

Canaanite slaves (or any non-Jewish) were usually bought from neighboring countries or people.  They were treated as proselytes to Judaism in that men underwent circumcision (hard on an adult male) and the women were subject to the laws pertaining to the women, so they underwent a class teaching these laws.  A slave's marriage was arranged by his master.  Children were property of the owner. 

  A Hebrew slave in Egypt being beaten by the one in charge

Although a master could beat a slave under Jewish law much later, to kill him was still murder and not allowed.  If in the act a master destroyed the slave's eye, tooth, etc, the slave went free.  Remember, Moses witnessed a Hebrew slave being beaten and was so appalled that he attacked the one in charge and then accidently killed him in his rage!  Even murder was not allowed in Egypt, so Moses himself had to leave and went to Midian.  

Peter, an escaped slave in 1863 during Civil war in BATON ROUGE, LOUISIANA, 1863., shows his back, reason enough for escaping; constant horrible whipping.  Note:  From 1728 to 1803, the land became part of the US and the Black Code prohibited the practice of any religion other than Roman Catholicism.  However, there were Jews living in Louisiana from 1719 onwards.  In 1828 the 1st synagogue was built.  More than 200 Louisiana Jews served in the Confederate army during the Civil War.  Most Jews lived in New Orleans.  

A slave who escaped was not handed back to his master, and according to rabbinic law, one who had reached Palestine, automatically regained his freedom.  Freed slaves were considered as proselytes in every respect.  

This made more sense during the Middle Ages when Jewish merchants were engaged to some extent in the slave trade, but because of the danger entailed, especially in Christian lands, the slaves generally remained non-Jewish.  Nevertheless, the benediction to be recited on the occasion of the circumcision of a slave continued to figure in some Sephardi prayer books down to the 17th century or in India to the 19th century.  

There were Jewish slave-owner in the West Indies and the southern states of the US.  Many Jews were prominent, however, in the struggle which finally led to the abolition of slavery.  

Individual Jews in the US such as Judah Touro were among the 1st to free their slaves.  American Jews as a whole took no stand in the slavery debates which preceded and continued through the American Civil War.  But many individuals were active in the abolitionist Cause such as Michael Heilprin, August Bondi, and Rabbis Einhorn, Feisenthal, Adler, and Szold.

On the other hand, Rabbi Morris J. Raphall of New York city declared publicly in 1861 that the Bible sanctioned slavery.  Leaving out the rest of the discussion was like telling a lie.  Others had their own idea of treatment of slaves that were not Jewish thoughts. Look again at Peter's back.   

A number of Jews assisted in the "Underground Railway" that smuggled slaves to free states and Canada.  Jews who fought for abolition on the political front included Sigismund Kaufman, Philip J. Joachimsen, and Abraham Kohn.  

Resource:

Book:  the New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia-Slavery

https://www.history.com/news/whipped-peter-slavery-photo-scourged-back-real-story-civil-war


 



Friday, May 5, 2017

The Temple Mount and Us Jews

Nadene Goldfoot                                          
The Muslim's Dome of the Rock sits right in the middle of the Temple Mount.  It was built by Caliph Abd al-Malik in about 738 to replace the temporary structure put up 100 years earlier by Caliph Omar.  Omar had built his over the Roman's Temple they had built on this site after burning down Solomon's 2nd Temple in 70 CE.   Mohammad had died in 632 and that's when his followers really started proselytizing their new Islamic faith.  

There has been much thought and consternation centering around the Temple Mount in Jerusalem and it's rules for Jews going there to pray.  We've had the problem of not being allowed by the Arab authority of not being allowed to pray there or even be close to where the 2nd Temple had stood.  Orthodox Jewry tell us we shouldn't for certain reasons and so do the Jordanian authority and surrounding Palestinians.

The problem lies in the Muslim act of building a Mosque over the Temple site, the Mosque of Omar, and for us, the interrupting of the sanctity of the area. "After Israel captured the site 1967, the Chief Rabbinate of Israel announced that entering the Temple Mount was forbidden to Jews, in accordance with a halakhic prohibition against temei ha'met (Impurity by contacting the dead, cemeteries etc.). The ancient ban on Jews, other than a high priest, entering the zone of the Holy of Holies was confirmed, with the consideration also that, since the exact location of the Second Temple was unknown, any Jew walking through the site would be at grave risk of inadvertently treading on the ground of the Holy of Holies in error."   The Holy of Holies measured 32.5 x 32.5 and was oriented E-W.  I take this to be in feet.  It was surrounded outside by an abutting 3 story structure divided into cells and rooms used to store vessels and treasure.  The Holy of Holies had contained the Ark.  There is much that is recorded about it in its description.  Perhaps it's location can be re-created.  
                                                                 
They also have another Mosque there, the al Aqsa Mosque.  ""the Farthest Mosque"), also known as Al-Aqsa and Bayt al-Muqaddas, is the third holiest site in Sunni Islam.  Muslims believe that Muhammad was transported from the Sacred Mosque in Mecca to al-Aqsa during the Night JourneyIslamic tradition holds that Muhammad led prayers towards this site until the seventeenth month after the emigration, when God directed him to turn towards the Kaaba."  The original has been destroyed by earthquakes and rebuilt several times.  So Jews really have to watch where they are trying to pray.   This "silver-domed mosque sits, along with the Dome of the Rockseventeen gates, and four minarets,  on the Temple Mount and that leaves one place where Jews have been allowed to pray, the Western Wall; Kotel in Hebrew.  It used to be called the Wailing Wall.  The UN has been doing their best to keep Jews away from this as well by wanting to shut down all of East Jerusalem to Jews.  Luckily, they have no real power to do so.    All the tourists that come to Israel usually head for Jerusalem first thing and go to the kotel.  Even my Hebrew class  did when we were able to take a trip by bus.  You don't go that far and not want to walk on the ground near such a special site, and to be caught moving your lips and to be in trouble is just too harsh.  

 If you don't believe me about all the reasons and considerations that go into reading this ruling, read this article about all the conditions that are discussed about it by the rabbis.     "Entering the Temple Mount - in Halacha and Jewish History"  http://www.hakirah.org/Vol%2010%20Messner.pdf"

  When decisions had to be made about something, the Sanhedrin met and discussed all the ramifications.  It was like a preparation for debating.  The Sanhedrin was the meeting together of 71 ordained rabbis of the level of Harvard or Yale scholarship which functioned both as Supreme Court and as the legislature.  At the head stood the Nasi, usually a descendant of Hillel, and an Av Bet Din (father of the court).  The Vice-president of the Supreme Court was called the Bet Din ha-Gadol) and was in Jerusalem during the 2nd Temple period.  He probably handled the court procedure.  Today we have had 2 rabbis;  one Ashkenazi and one Sephardi.  No matter what they say as to whether we should be praying in this area or not, the Arabs are not allowing us even minutes of time to do so anyway.  They get violent when they see a Jew moving his lips as if in prayer and we get mad for not being able to say a prayer while standing in such a spot.                                                    
Jews not being allowed to pray on Temple Mount; 2015 
In the spirit of keeping the peace, it was Moshe Dayan who made the decision of allowing the Jordanians ruling over the Temple Mount.  They turned out to have been most narrow minded about doing their gracious bit by allowing Jews to say a quiet prayer near their mosque.  No, Jews are not allowed to say any prayers there.  It's a ridiculous reason to start a fight or war over.
                                                                       
                                                                                 
The Temple Mount, which is situated on top of Mount Moriah in Jerusalem, was selected to be the site of the 1st Temple by King Solomon.  It was the shrine for the Ark, the sacred vessels and offerings, with a court for worshipers.  It was designed and had a hall, shrine and inner sanctum or the holy of holies sections.  According to our records, the Temple was chosen to be built here because it was the very site where Abraham prepared to offer Isaac.  It was also the site of the threshing floor of Araunah the Jebusite that was bought by David on which to build an altar.  Jebusites were Canaanite people who had been living in the hilly part of the land around Jerusalem before Israelites had entered with Moses.  Jerusalem was occupied by them only in the reign of David.  The last Jebusite king was evidently this Araunah.  When David took it over, the Jebusites remained in the city and became a paying tributary group to Solomon which kept the peace.   After a period of time, they simply were assimilated.

 "From the days of Rabbi Yehoshua, Rabban Gamiliel, Rabbi Eliezer, and Rabbi Akiva, who lived through the destruction of the Holy Temple by the Romans, and whose joint ascent to the Temple Mount, after its destruction, is recorded in Talmud, (Massechet Makot), Jews have been ascending the Temple Mount, (when the foreign powers that ruled the Mount throughout the ages allowed it)."  So it has been done by the most orthodox of Jews after Jerusalem fell.  Is it not a recent decision that it is not to be visited by Jews because of the Holy of Holies issue ?  
                                                                                   
Police must use shields to protect themselves from Palestinian rock throwers
There has been a lot of fights, even stabbings, centering around Jews wanting to pray beside the ruins of our 1st and 2nd Temples that lie here, now in space invaded by Muslim invaders.  This plays a big part in Jerusalem being coveted by the Muslims and Jews with their ancient history right here being denied the simple act of praying here.

It started with the above rabbis of the 1st century of going to the Temple Mount.  Gamaliel the Elder was from the early 1st century and was president of the Sanhedrin at Jerusalem; grandson of Hillel.  He communicated with Jewish communities in Judah, which was called Palestine after 135 CE.  He also was able to communicate with Jews in the Diaspora as well.  The communications were about such things as writing several regulations directed at social improvements based on the Torah such as the betterment of the legal position of women.  

Rabbi Akiva Ben Joseph lived from about the year 50 to 135 of humble origin and was an uneducated person until he was 40 when  with his wife's backing, devoted himself to learning.  He studied with many leading scholars and developed his own style of biblical interpretation according to which every word and sign in the Bible has a particular significance and can be used to establish a source for accepted halakhic decisions.  He collected and arranged the whole Oral Law according to subjects.  This rabbi was regarded as the greatest scholar of his time, and thousands of students studied at his school in Bene Berak, Israel.  He was one most interested in mystical speculation and was the only one of 4 rabbis who studied mysticism and was not harmed by it..  He went with Rabbi Gamaliel and others to Rome to secure the reversal of Domitian's legislation against the Jews.  They journeyed widely among Jewish communities outside Palestine.  This is one rabbi who backed the idea of Bar Kokhba being the king-messiah.  Jerusalem had fallen to the Romans in 70CE and it was in 132 that Bar Kokhba, with them men he had gathered, fought against the Romans in a 3 year battle and was able to take back this holy city for the 3 years, but then he was killed in battle in 135 and the Romans regained control.  

Famous rabbis made such a ruling at the beginning of our loss 2,000 years ago, and now events have progressed.  We are back after a very long period and Jerusalem is our capital, like it or not, world.  Must we wait till the 3rd Temple is built?  The true acceptance by our neighbors would be to allow us to say prayers.  Wouldn't that be a sight?  Jews, Muslims and Christians all praying to G-d for peace on earth, good will towards mankind.  

Resource:   "Entering the Temple Mount - in Halacha and Jewish History" 
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/213261
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temple_Mount_entry_restrictions
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Aqsa_Mosque
The New Standard Jewish Enyclopedia