Showing posts with label Judith Feld Carr. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Judith Feld Carr. Show all posts

Thursday, January 8, 2026

Aleppo, Syria; Once the Stronghold of Jewish Industry, Now Fighting the Good Guys, The Kurds

 Nadene Goldfoot                                               

                                           The Jews of Syria, A Lost Civilization

Stiff European trade competition in the late 1800‘s, bolstered by the opening of the Suez Canal, caused severe economic hardship for Syrian-Jewish merchants. Many Jews emigrated to Lebanon, Israel, and elsewhere while the Jews of Damascus declined in religiosity. The Jewish population of Aleppo stayed steady, but that of Damascus decreased dramatically over a short period of time. Today some 50 Jews remain in Syria. Their population blame any little thing, like the bad weather, on the Jews.  Their Damascus Affair is a well-known anti-Semic event of that period.   

You need a game board to keep track of who the good guys are these days and what is happening to them.  Aleppo was a major, ancient Jewish center, known as "Aram-Zoba," with a history stretching back to biblical times, famous for its Great Synagogue, vibrant Sephardic culture absorbing Spanish exiles, and as the home of the priceless Aleppo Codex. Its Jewish community, a unique blend of indigenous and Sephardic traditions, thrived under Ottoman rule, becoming a significant scholarly and merchant hub before facing persecution and eventual mass emigration in the mid-20th century, with remnants now in Israel, the U.S., and Latin America. 

While Damascus was the biggest Jewish center, the second major Jewish center in Syria was Aleppo. Jewish activity there dates back to the 4th century C.E. with the building of the Kanisat Mutakal, the oldest Jewish structure in Aleppo. As Aleppo became the center of Jewish learning in Syria, several notable figures including Saadiah Gaon and R. Joseph b. Aknin (the Rambam’s disciple) made their way there from Israel to see the Aleppo community’s erudition and first-hand. They could not have been disappointed for the Jewish scholars of Aleppo were responsible for producing one of Judaism’s single most important documents and Syrian Jewry’s single greatest achievement: the Aleppo Codex. The Codex is the most authoritative and accurate of the Masoretic Texts which form the basis for the modern Hebrew text of the Bible. 

By the time of the Six-Day War of 1967 there were only 1,000 Jews in Aleppo and 1,500 in Damascus, down from 40,000 total Jews in 1948. The socialist Ba’ath party took over in 1963 putting into power Hafez al-Assad and later his son, the current president, Bashar. 

 

I wrote about Judith Feld Carr helping the Syrian Jews get out of Syria in my book, Messages From A Syrian Jew Trapped in Egypt.    Despite their dire situation, the Jews of Syria were not forgotten by the outside world. One hero in particular, Judy Feld Carr, was instrumental in bringing about what is one of the largest post-Holocaust rescue of Jews. Carr, a Canadian-Jewish musician, used funds from the Dr. Ronald Feld Fund for Jews in Arab Lands from the Beth Tzedek Synagogue in Toronto to pay for Syrian Jews to emigrate to a place of their choosing. Over the course of 25 years, an estimated 3,228 Jews were able to leave Syria thanks to Carr’s clandestine efforts. She has won numerous awards and is the subject of a book, The Ransomed of God: The Remarkable Story Of One Woman's Role in the Rescue of Syrian Jews by Harold Troper. 

What's happening  today in Aleppo:  

  • Escalating Clashes: Fighting intensified in Kurdish-majority neighborhoods (Sheikh Maqsoud, Ashrafiyeh) after a brief ceasefire, with shelling hitting civilian areas. (The Kurds are our friends. 
  • Why is Syria fighting them?) The recent fighting between the Syrian government and the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) stems from a fundamental disagreement over the SDF-held territories' future: autonomy versus central state control. The long-running Syrian civil war provided the context for this conflict, allowing the Kurds to establish a semi-autonomous region in the northeast.                     
                                                         

  • Who are the Kurds?  The Kurds are a large, indigenous Middle Eastern ethnic group, numbering 30-45 million, known as the world's largest stateless people, living primarily in Kurdistan, a region spanning parts of TurkeyIraqIran, and Syria, united by Kurdish (an Indo-European language) and culture but with diverse traditions, predominantly Sunni Muslim, who have a long history of seeking autonomy or independence amidst persecution and conflict. 
  • What is connection of Kurds and Jews?  DNA studies show Kurds and Jews share close genetic ties, with Kurds often being the closest relatives to most Jewish groups, clustering more with populations from the northern Fertile Crescent (Kurds, Turks, Armenians) than Arabs; both groups exhibit common ancestral markers like the Cohen Modal Haplotype (CMH), linking them to ancient northern Middle Eastern populations, suggesting shared deep roots in the region. 
  • What side was Israel on?  Israel has provided covert military, intelligence, and financial assistance to the Kurds, primarily in Iraq, since the 1960s, and has offered humanitarian aid and political support for independence in recent decades. 
  • Civilian Impact: At least five civilians died, dozens injured, and over 30,000 displaced; hospitals suspended operations, and flights at Aleppo Airport were halted.
  • Evacuation Orders: Syrian authorities urged residents to leave contested zones, opening corridors as military operations against the SDF loomed.
  • SDF Stance: The SDF claims government forces have besieged Kurdish areas for months and denies military presence in Aleppo, holding internal security forces responsible. 
        All he needed was to put on a suit, and the panther  Jolani changed his clothes to Sharaa..  
  • Syria seems to be going from bad to worse.  Syria's new president is Ahmed al-Sharaa (also known as Ahmad al-Shara), a former jihadist who led the rebel offensive that ousted Bashar al-Assad in late 2024, becoming president for a transitional period.  Ahmed al-Sharaa, the current de facto leader of Syria, used to be widely known by his jihadist nom de guerreAbu Mohammad al-Jolani (or al-Julani), a former commander for al-Qaeda and the Islamic State (ISIS) in Iraq and Syria, designated a global terrorist by the U.S. before his rebranding and rise in Syrian politics. 
  • Trump loves this guy, but we know better. Does a leopard change his  sspots overnight?    
  •  He has since rebranded himself as a moderate leader, shedding his past ties to al-Qaeda (formerly Hayat Tahrir al-Sham/HTS), engaging with Western nations, and focusing on rebuilding Syria, though challenges remain in establishing stable governance and addressing the country's humanitarian crisis. 


Resource:

https://jewishbubba.blogspot.com/2024/10/messages-from-syrian-jew-trapped-in.html

Saturday, November 16, 2024

Prophecy and Facts About Damascus, Syria

 Nadene Goldfoot                                                  


According to the Bible, the city of Damascus will be destroyed and will no longer be inhabitedIsaiah 17:1-3:  "Behold, Damascus will cease from being a city, and it will be a ruinous heap". The prophecy also states that the cities of Aroer will be deserted and used by flocks, and that the kingdom of Damascus will be gone.  Isaiah prophesied in Jerusalem from 740 BCE-701 BCE) He was from a noble family, closely related to the royal court and active in public affairs;  lived from the death of Uzziah until the middle of Hezekiah's reign .  
                              Jordan River, Amon River, Zered River is shown above;  Ammon is shown

The Bible mentions two cities named Aroer, one on the Arnon and one on the border of Ammon:
  • Aroer on the Arnon
    Located on the north bank of the Arnon  River, east of the Dead Sea, in present-day Jordan. It was an ancient Moabite settlement that was later given to the Reubenites and Gadites by Moses. The city was famous in the history of Jephthah and David. It is now known as the modern village of 'Ara'ir.   The Arnon River is in Jordan, not Lebanon or Syria today: Also known as the Wadi Mujib, this river is located in Jordan and empties into the Dead Sea. It was an important boundary in ancient times, separating the Moabites from the Amorites and later the tribes of Reuben and Gad. The name Arnon is Hebrew and means "torrent valley". 
  • The cities of Aroer are mentioned in the Bible in the following passages:  Deuteronomy 4:48;  Judges 11:26;  2 Kings 10:33;  Joshua 12:2;  Numbers 32:34;  Joshua 13:25;  2 Samuel 24:5;  Isaiah 17:2 :   and 
  • Jeremiah 48:18-20;  and   Jeremiah 49:23-27 ;  The prophecy states that Damascus will be in fear and anguish, and that her young men will fall in her streets. 
  • It also says that the Lord will kindle a fire in the wall of Damascus and consume the palaces of Ben-Hadad I, who ruled from 885–865 BCE, Ben-Hadad I was the son of Tabrimmon and grandson of Hezion. He formed a league with King Asa of Judah to attack the northern kingdom of Israel. 
  • Ben-Hadad I was murdered by Hazael. The name "Ben-Hadad" is Hebrew for "Son of Hadad". Hadad was the name of a senior Aramean deity.
                         Ephraim, one of Jacob's 12 sons' tribes and the Arameans:  
  • Judah, with Benjamin and Simeon cooperated while the 9-10 rest were captured as Israel by Assyria later on   in 721 BCE.  

  • 'Behold, Damascus is about to be removed from being a city and will become a fallen ruin. The cities of Aroer are forsaken; they will be for flocks to lie down in, and there will be no one to frighten them. The fortified city will disappear from Ephraim, and sovereignty from Damascus…. and the rest of Aram '”* Isaiah 17:1-3  This was telling of the breakup of the land of the  Ephramite-Aramean alliance,  also being used as a prophesy for the End of Times.  
         Damascus today: 
    Damascus  is the capital and largest city of Syria, the oldest current capital in the world and, according to some, the fourth holiest city in Islam. Known colloquially in Syria as aš-Šām  and dubbed, poetically, the "City of Jasmine" Damascus is a major cultural center of the Levant and the Arab world.

  • Between 1975 and 2000, Judith Feld Carr smuggled 3,000 Jews, living mostly on "Jew Street" in Damascus, out and into freedom.  Judy came across an article from The Jerusalem Post that reported on the tragic deaths of 12 Syrian Jewish men, who ran across a minefield while attempting to flee the country to Turkey. Judy was struck by the fact that the Syrian guards callously stood by and watched them die, one by one.
Which reminds me.  Every evening when the TV news was over, Syria had a routine of saying good-night with their army troops.  On our TV  in Israel we could get stations from Jordan, Syria and Egypt that I remember.   I remember seeing that they would show how scary they were by harming puppies.  I won't say more, but it is a gruesome memory.  I can say that I was very glad my Syrian friend from facebook was a very kind person and loved dogs.  He had thought his birth-mother had been Jewish, daughter of a jeweler from "Jew Street."  
Damascus is a significant city in the Bible, appearing in both the Old and New Testaments.  Damascus is where my message-friend lived who was living in Damascus at the time of their Civil War.  He and his family fled to Egypt.  He had a college degree from Lebanon and was an engineer.   
Today, Israel is at war with the terror groups Hamas and Hezbollah, supported by Iran who wants Israel's downfall.  Two days ago Israel hit military sites in Damascus;   the attacks targeted military sites and the headquarters of the Islamic Jihad group..  Syrians reported that 15 were killed, but most likely far less including injured.  Israel has been carrying out strikes against Iran-linked targets in Syria for years but has ramped up such raids since last year's Oct. 7 attack by Palestinian militant group, Hamas on Israel that sparked the Gaza war.
Israel’s military says Islamic Jihad participated alongside the Palestinian militant group Hamas in the Oct. 7, 2023 attacks from Gaza into Israel that killed some 1,200 people — mostly civilians — and saw 250 others abducted.  Aji reported from Damascus, Syria. 
Reference:
Book:  Messages From A Syrian Jew Trapped In Egypt, by Nadene Goldfoot with Jack Huffman, Storyteller
Tanach, The Stone Edition (Bible)

Monday, February 8, 2021

UN Scapegoating Israel by BDS With Palestinians and Syrians

 Nadene Goldfoot                                           

                                                           Syrian Jewish Woman 
       Since Syria borders Israel, it has also had a big population of Jews.  In the 12th century,  the 3 largest Jewish populations in Syria were in Palmyra with 12,000, Aleppo with 5,000 and Damascus with 3,000.  More Jews came into Syria after 1492's Spanish Inquisition.   Syria became an important center of transit trade between Europe and Asia.  Jews finally received equal rights with the Arabs in Syria under the French mandate of 1920, but these were infringed during WWII under the Vichy regime.  With anti-Jewish feeling reaching a climax in the late 1930s and early 1940s, many Jews considered emigrating. During WWI, between 1942 and 1947, around 4,500 Jews arrived in Palestine from Syria and Lebanon.  From 1945 to 1948, about 1,300 Syrian Jewish children were smuggled into Palestine.  In 1943 many Syrian Jews emigrated to the USA, Israel and Lebanon which reduced Syria's Jewish population from 30,000 to 14,000 by 1947.  By 1973, 4,000 Jews were left in Syria.  

After Israel's victory in the 1967 Six-Day War, restrictions were further tightened, and 57 Jews in Qamishli may have been killed in a pogrom. The communities of Damascus, Aleppo, and Qamishli were under house arrest for eight months following the war. Many Jewish workers were laid off following the Six-Day Civil War.                                                           

The Zeibak sisters: Four Syrian-Jewish girls (three sisters and their cousin) who were raped, killed, and mutilated while trying to flee to Israel in 1974

As a result, Syrian Jews began escaping clandestinely, and supporters abroad helped smuggle Jews out of Syria. Syrian Jews already living abroad often bribed officials to help Jews escape. Judith Feld Carr, a Canadian-Jewish activist, helped smuggle 3,228 Jews out of Syria to Israel, the United States, Canada, and Latin America. Carr recalled that Syrian-Jewish parents were "desperate" to get their children out of the country.  Those who were caught attempting to escape faced execution or forced labor. If an escape was successful, family members could be imprisoned and stripped of their property. Often with the help of smugglers, escapees attempted to sneak across the border into Lebanon or Turkey, where they were met and assisted by undercover Israeli agents or local Jewish communities. Most escapees were young and single men. Many single men decided to put off marriage until they escaped, as they wanted to raise their children in freedom. As a result, the ratio of single men and women became heavily imbalanced, and Syrian Jewish women were often unable to find husbands. In 1977, Syrian President Hafez al-Assad, as a gesture to US President Jimmy Carter, began allowing limited numbers of young women to leave the country, and some 300 left in total under this program.  As I remember, my facebook friend was born in 1980.  His mother, he had said, was a Jewish Syrian. 

                                                                 

 Judith Feld Carr, a Canadian Jew, managed to get all Jews out of Syria at a time they were ghettoized with the promise to  President Assad that they wouldn't be taken to Israel.  That left very few in Syria.  I had a facebook friend, Jack,  a Syrian, who swore he had found out that his birth mother had been Jewish.  He had been looking for her.  Judith couldn't find a record on her, being he didn't know her name.  She and his father had married secretly, being it was an offense in Syria to marry a Jew.  Today, Israel has 115,000 Syrian Jews; US has 75,000, Argentina has 40,000, Mexico has 16,000 and Panama has 10,000.  

                                                           


Palestinians have always said since 1880 that they were Syrians, and had entered Palestine wanting to work for the Russian Jewish settlers on the 1st Aliyah.   Joan Peters, in her deep research, found this to be true.  A DNA test would probably also attest to their heritage, as well. 

genetic study from 2000 shows that many Arabs and Jews are closely related. More than 70% of Jewish men and half of the Arab men whose DNA was studied inherited their Y chromosomes from the same paternal ancestors who lived in the region within the last few thousand years.  Geneticist Michael Hammer of the University of Arizona in Tucson found that the Y chromosome in Middle Eastern Arabs was almost indistinguishable from that of Jews.  Geneticist Ariella Oppenheim of Hebrew University in Jerusalem, who collaborated on the earlier study, focused on Arab and Jewish men. Her team examined the Y chromosomes of 119 Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews and 143 Israeli and Palestinian Arabs. Many of the Jewish subjects were descended from ancestors who presumably originated in the Levant but dispersed throughout the world before returning to Israel in the past few generations; most of the Arab subjects could trace their ancestry to men who had lived in the region for centuries or longer. The Y chromosomes of many of the men had key segments of DNA that were so similar that they clustered into just three of many groups known as haplogroups. Other short segments of DNA called microsatellites were similar enough to reveal that the men must have had common ancestors within the past several thousand years. The YDNA haplogroup of 520 Syrian Arabs tested showed a 55.7% being J.  The same for 143 Palestinians tested showed 55.2% as J.  This didn't differentiate between J1 or J2.   An autosomal test should show any differences.  We Jews also show this.  J is called the Cohen gene of which Aaron and his brother, Moses also had.  We always said that the Arabs were our distant cousins. it said that in the Torah along with the  genealogical information.  Obviously, we are not kissing cousins.  .                                                                      

Since the beginning of the Civil War of Syria that has lasted for 9 years,  3,400 Palestinians were killed in Syria from the bombings, artillery strikes, prison tortures, disease and starvation.  It has been 9 years, 10 months, 3 weeks and 3 days since the Syrian Day of Rage protests were gathered on 15 March 2011, and 8 years, 6 months, 3 weeks and 3 days since the Red Cross declared the situation to be a civil war.

Palestinians have now taken their place as refugee camps have been installed in Syria to hold them.  The Yarmouk Refugee Camp near Damascus  held 150,000.   By 2017, less than 18,000 lived there.   It was reported that people were foraging for leaves, cats and dogs for food, trying to live without electricity or water.  Yarmouk is an "unofficial" refugee camp; It was home to the largest Palestinian refugee community in Syria. ... After intense fighting in April/May 2018, Syrian government forces took the camp, its population now reduced to 100-200.

Since the beginning of the Civil War of Syria that has lasted for 9 years,  3,400 Palestinians were killed in Syria from the bombings, artillery strikes, prison tortures, disease and starvation.  

The UN and the BDS movement have been smearing Israel's great reputation from the 1967 days of their miraculous win against the barrage of Muslim countries who had attacked them.  BDS is led by a Palestinian movement against Israel for its very existence.                                                                    

Bob Horenstein of Portland, Oregon visited the Ziv Medical Center in Safed on or before 2017  which had been my hospital while living in Safed from 1980 to the end of 1985.  Since 2013, Ziv had treated over 700 Syrians including 121 children.  They had treated many earlier when I lived there.  Helicopters brought the wounded in, landing on the roof of the hospital.  My students could hear them come in and worried if they were bringing in their fathers or uncles or brothers-or the enemy.    Most of those  injured were suffering from severe blast wounds from mines or rocket fire.  Many of the children had lost at least one limb.  During the battle in 1981, my 9th grade students had been translators for the doctors as they had patients that were the enemy being treated there.  Our junior high where I taught was right across the street from this hospital.  They told me they saw things they shouldn't have been able to see.  I guess some were in some gruesome conditions.                                                                

         By resolution 2334 (2016)  the Council demanded that Israel immediately and completely cease all settlement activities.

Assad had been massacring his own people in his Civil War.  However, the UN only saw Israel as a culprit with their December 2016 Security Council 2334 with 20 resolutions condemning Israeli settlement activity. etc,  that was drafted by Syria, rebuking Israel for repressive measures against the population of "occupied Syrian Golan."  Israel had received 20 out of the 24 sanctions and Syria had received one!   As a geopolitical region, the Golan Heights refers to the area captured from Syria and occupied by Israel during the 1967 Six-Day War, territory which has been administered as part of Israel since 1981.  The Golan was under military administration until the Knesset passed the Golan Heights Law in 1981, which applied Israeli law to the territory; a move that has been described as an annexation. In response, the United Nations Security Council unanimously passed UNSC Resolution 497 which condemned the Israeli actions to change the status of the territory declaring them "null and void and without international legal effect", and that the Golan remained an occupied territory. In 2019 under Trump,  the United States became the only state to recognize the Golan Heights as Israeli sovereign territory, while the rest of the international community continues to consider the territory Syrian held under Israeli military occupation.  The Golan Heights Law is the Israeli law which applies Israel's government and laws to the Golan Heights. It was ratified by the Knesset by a vote of 63―21, on December 14, 1981. ... The law was passed half a year after the peace treaty with Egypt which included Israeli withdrawal from the Sinai Peninsula.                                                

Citing a passage from Leviticus she said her late husband often quoted, “Thou shalt not stand idly by the blood of thy neighbor,” Georgette Bennett met with the CEO of a major Jewish aid group and quickly got him to agree to head a Jewish effort for the refugees. Bennett, a former professor, journalist and philanthropist, supplied the first $100,000.  

The CEO, Alan Gill of the American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee, got more than a dozen Jewish groups to sign on to the campaign, dubbed the Jewish Coalition for Syrian Refugees in Jordan. So far, more than $344,000 has been collected, most of it allocated to groups working with refugees in Jordan.  Only three have posted prominent appeals on their websites. And only one, the JDC, has contributed any money of its own — $50,000, according to a spokesman.  The biggest contributor so far has been Bennett herself, who has now put in a total of $150,000.

In a separate effort, the Israeli group IsraAid has been providing mattresses and food-and-hygiene packages to refugee families in urban areas in northern Jordan for the last year. As with the coalition’s effort, IsraAid is working with locals, but Israeli staffers have been traveling to Jordan every few weeks to coordinate the effort.  Many other groups have now joined in.  “The Jewish community understands tikkun olam:  understands humanitarian responsibility,” said Will Recant, an assistant executive vice president at the JDC. “When they were made aware, they started to step forward just as they did for Darfur, Rwanda and other areas of humanitarian need.”                   


The cost of caring for the Syrians had been about $5 million, paid for almost totally by Israel.  The UN contributed nothing.  This is the entity that denounced Israel for "violations of the Geneva Convention relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons."  The irony of this is that:  within a decade of Israel's founding, the government and its people demonstrated a deep commitment to engage in humanitarian relief efforts and international development programs. In 1958, Israel adopted an official humanitarian aid agenda as a principal element of the country's international cooperation efforts. Over the years, the country has extended international humanitarian aid assistance to more than 140 countries, even to those who do not maintain diplomatic relations with the Jewish state.

The UN and others have been scapegoating Israel which is hypocrisy and is obscene.  It appears that now in 2020-2021, things are changing with the peace formed with 4 Islamic countries.  Perhaps one day the UN will stop picking on Israel, whose whole religion of Judaism is centered around morality of which Christianity and Islam have borrowed.  Of all the countries in the world, Israel has a very high standard to live up to of their own, regardless of what others think.  

Resource:

The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Syrian_Jews

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Security_Council_Resolution_2334

The Jerusalem Report, February 6, 2017, p. 9  Robert "Bob" Horenstein, director for the Jewish Federation of Greater Portland

Messages From A Syrian Jew trapped in Egypt, by Nadene Goldfoot

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Y-DNA_haplogroups_in_populations_of_the_Near_East

https://www.un.org/unispal/data-collection/security-council/

https://www.jta.org/2013/09/11/united-states/jewish-groups-sending-aid-to-syrian-refugees-sort-of

https://mfa.gov.il/mfa/foreignpolicy/aid/pages/israel_on_frontline_international_aid.aspx