Showing posts with label disengagement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label disengagement. Show all posts

Saturday, July 5, 2025

Census of Israel and Gaza of 2014 and 2024

 Nadene Goldfoot                                               

                                                  Gaza Before 2005

In 2005, Israel unilaterally withdrew all Israeli settlers and military forces from the Gaza Strip.  Approximately 8,000 to 9,000 Israeli settlers were moved out of the Gaza Strip during Israel's unilateral disengagement in 2005. This withdrawal involved dismantling all 21 Israeli towns/settlements in the territory. 

This action, known as the Israeli disengagement from the Gaza Strip, involved dismantling 21 Israeli towns in Gaza and four in the West Bank. The decision was driven by various factors, including the high costs and casualties associated with maintaining a presence in Gaza amidst fighting with Palestinian groups and concerns about the growing Palestinian population. The disengagement plan, proposed by Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, aimed to improve Israel's security and political situation by reducing friction with Palestinians and focusing on areas considered strategically important for Israel. Although Israel withdrew its physical presence, the United Nations and other international organizations still consider Gaza to be under Israeli occupation due to Israel's control over its external affairs, as reaffirmed by a 2024 International Court of Justice opinion.

Things left for the Palestinians' use:

Israeli Settlements:
  • By 2005, there were 21 Israeli settlements in the Gaza Strip.
  • Examples include Kfar Darom, Netzarim, Morag, Eretz, Katif, Netzer Hazani, Elei Sinai, Dugit, and Nisanit. 
Other Infrastructure:
  • Roads: Existing road networks within the Gaza Strip.
  • Electricity Infrastructure: Power stations were present.
  • Water Infrastructure: Desalination plants existed.
  • Commercial Greenhouses: Present and utilized for trade.
  • Residential Buildings: Housing for the Palestinian population.
  • Refugee Camps: Housing for Palestinian refugees who fled or were driven from their homes during the 1948 war by their own leadership. 

        Tel Aviv

Israel:  Based on data from around the end of 2014:
  • Total Population: Around 8.3 million.
  • Jewish Population: Approximately 6.2 million (74.9% of the population).
  • Arab Population: Approximately 1.7 million (20.7% of the population).
  • Other Population: Around 4.3% (including Christians and individuals not identifying with a religion or nationality). 
Israel:                                                    
                                       Tel Aviv Today
  • Latest estimate (end of 2024): 10.027 million people. This included foreign nationals.
  • Jewish population: Approximately 7.7 million.
  • Arab population: Approximately 2.1 million.
  • Other residents: Approximately 216,000 foreigners and others not classified as Jewish or Arab. Gaza Strip:; Christians in this number
                                      Israel's LAND FOR PEACE :  GAZA

  • Gaza Strip:
  • Based on data from around the end of 2014
    • Total Population: Estimated at 1.76 million people at mid-2014, with around 1.79 million by the end of 2014.
    • Population Density: Very high at 4,822 persons/km².
    • Young Population: The population was relatively young, with a large percentage of individuals under 15 years old, constituting 43.2% of the population in Gaza Strip at mid-2014. Children aged five to nine formed the largest age group. 
Gaza Strip:                                        
                      Gaza 2025  Destruction 
  • Latest estimate (end of 2024): 2.1 million people. The largest age group would
  • have been children now aged 15 to 19. , fighting age.  
  • Decline in population: Gaza's population declined by 6% (about 160,000 people) in 2024 due to the conflict.
  • Refugee population: A large proportion of the population were refugees before the war. According to the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), there are eight official Palestine refugee camps in the Gaza Strip. So all homes were supplied by UNRWA.  They are now
  • probably all destroyed by the war.  

Wednesday, July 21, 2021

Gaza, Hope of Peace That Turned to War Despite Legalities, Part III

 Nadene Goldfoot                                           


 Gaza had been the city of the Philistines, main enemy of Jews since Joshua led the Israelites into Canaan.  The Philistines were a fighting -people by nature,  originating from Asia Minor and Greek locations,  reaching Canaan in various waves of the Mediterranean. One group arrived early and settled south of Beersheba in Gerar, coming into conflict with Abraham and Isaac.  Another group came from Crete after being kicked out by Egypt by Ramses II in 1194 BCE and they founded 5 places; Gaza, Ascalon, Ashdod, Ekron, and Gath.  Gaza had been used by the Egyptians of the 15th to 13th centuries BCE to serve as a base for Egyptian expeditions to the north when it was captured by the Philistines and  became their most important site by housing their temple of Dagon.  

                                                                       


Along came Joshua with the Israelites in about 1271 BCE  who allotted it to the tribe of Judah, the largest tribe of the 12 of Jacob.  However, though they should have been quite strong and healthy after walking for 40 years, the city remained in Philistine hands and was the place of the imprisonment and death of Samson.  

The Assyrians attacked this Northern city of Israel 551 years later in 720 BCE and it was annexed by King Sargon of Assyria who took the best lot of the people as slaves to Assyria.  199 years later in 521 BCE the city was taken by Cambyses of Persia.  Alexander the Great recolonized the city 189 years later as a Hellenistic city in 332 BCE.  When Alex died, Gaza was disputed over between the Egyptian Ptolemies and the Syrian Seleucids until Antiochus III of Syria ( Greek Hellenistic king and the 6th ruler of the Seleucid Empire. He ruled over the region of Syria and large parts of the rest of western Asia towards the end of the 3rd century BC.) annexed it in 198 BCE.  Gaza was independent in 110 for a few years but captured by Alexander Yannai in 96, when along came General Pompey declaring it a free city in 61 BCE.  We remember our holiday of Chanukah telling us of Antiochus of the Greek Syrians having taken over the Temple and putting in idols, forcing Jews to bow to them.  

During the Middle Ages, it was populated by Jews and Samaritans until its capture by Napoleon in 1799.  It became a center of Sabbetaism, a false messiah  period in the 17th century.  The Jews left the city in 1917, the end of WWI when discussions were going on to create Eretz Yisrael a Jewish state.  A few Jews returned  but left again during the 1929 Arab rioting.                                                           

 By 1949 Gaza became a main city with a population of 30,000 being swollen by many refugees.  It was captured in November 1956 by the Israel forces of IDF who remained there until March 1957. It again passed under Israel rule during the Six-Day War in 1967.  A census taken later that year gave its population at 119, 000.                                                                                                                              
The disengagement was proposed in 2003 by Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, adopted by the government in June 2004, and approved by the Knesset in February 2005 as the Disengagement Plan Implementation Law.

The Gaza Strip includes the town of Gaza, extending from the eastern border of Egypt north along the Palestinian coast for 22 miles with the average width of 8 miles.  It was the result of the Egyptian advance into the Negev in May 1948, and the Israel offensives of October to December 1948 which drove them out of the entire area, with the exception of the Gaza Strip.  The area remained under Egyptian rule according to the Armistice Agreement of 1949.  The Gaza Strip had also been until 1948, part of the British Mandate of Palestine.  Between 1948 and 1967, with a brief  interruption in 1956-1957, following the Sinai War, it was administered by an Egyptian Military Government.  It was not annexed by Egypt.   

The Gaza Strip had become the focus of military and political tension by 1955, and in November 1956, was captured by Israeli forces in the course of the SINAI  War.  Under UN and especially US pressure, Israel returned the Gaza Strip in March 1957, when Egyptians resumed control with a UN emergency Force stationed along the border with Israel.  

In May 1967,  the UN secretary-general U Thant accceded to a demand by Nasser to withdraw the UN force, thereby precipitating the events leading to the Six-Day War when the Gaza Strip again passed under Israel control.  It has been the scene of frequent unrest.  The 1967 census found 352,260 in the Gaza Strip of whom 172,520 were refugees.  By July 1972, there were 388,600 in the Gaza Strip (360 sq. km-140 sq miles. 

                                                                              

In August 2005, the State of Israel “disengaged” from the Gaza Strip, removing all Israeli military installations, 25 Israeli settlements (4 in the West Bank) with over 8,000 residents. The Israel disengagement was unilateral, and was not the result of negotiations with the Palestinians.  Israelis left everything for the Palestinians, even their businesses there, such as greenhouses.  

“The purpose of the disengagement plan is to reduce terrorism as much as possible, and grant Israeli citizens the maximum level of security. The process of disengagement will lead to an improvement in the quality of life, and will help strengthen the Israeli economy.” The disengagement plan required the uprooting and resettlement of 25 Israeli communities in the Gaza Strip.  The decision was made in the name of peace, hoping for a better future for both.  

When the Israeli government made its decision to disengage from Gaza in 2005, Gaza was home to over 1,324,991 people. Roughly 99.4 percent of the population was Palestinian and 0.06 percent was Jewish. Forty-nine percent of the population there was age 14 and under. The birth rate was 40.62 births/1,000 population with a fertility rate of 6.04 children born/woman. Demographically, Gaza was a challenging place for any authority to administer.

Opponents of the plan argued that Israel was retreating from Gaza“under fire” – that the decision to disengage was a capitulation to Palestinian terrorism, and not in the context of mutually agreed concessions. The Gaza Strip contained 21 civilian Israeli communities.  They all had to leave.   

    In the Gaza Strip (21 communities):

                                                                         

    While the Israeli military fully withdrew from the Gaza Strip in the disengagement, Hamas-controlled Gaza (it took over the territory in 2007) represents a serious security challenge to Israel. In response to Hamas terrorist attacks and the launching of thousands of rockets at Israeli population centers, the IDF has conducted military operations (aerially or on the ground) against Hamas in Gaza in 2008/9, 2012 and 2014. 

    The turning over Gaza to the Palestinians showed up quickly as a big error.  They voted in the Hamas terrorists as their governing body.   "After Israel's withdrawal, the Palestinians were given control over the Gaza Strip, except for the borders, the airspace and the territorial waters.  On September 23, hours after rockets were shot into Israel, and the fight was on.  Israel retaliated.   A Hamas pickup truck in the Jabaliya refugee camp was struck by a missile, killing at least 19 people (both militants and civilians) and injuring 85 people. On September 26, Israel killed Palestinian Islamic Jihad commander Mohammad Khalil and his bodyguard with a missile strike; on September 29 Israel closed all Hamas charities on the West Bank, and as part of a five-day offensive fired artillery into the Gaza Strip.                                                      

        Rockets are fired from the Gaza Strip toward Israel, on November 13, 2019

    Sirens throughout the night cried out  in Israel as multiple rocket salvos launched from Gaza.

    Israel and Egypt control the flow of imports into Gaza due to Hamas’ misuse and misappropriation of goods for military purposes.                                                                                             

    Tunnel found, dug out by Gazans to bring in ammunition, attack Israelis, etc.  

    Cities near the border of Gaza have been under constant daily attack by rockets from Gaza.  It was turned into the base of attack on Israel.  Gazans have even built a tunnel to receive ammunition to use on Israel.                                                   

      

    The recent rocket attack in May  of the barrage of 4,340 from Gaza lasted 11 days. Israelis had to hunker down in their bomb shelters in their lengthy surprise attack.  The Gazans harmed themselves as Israel had to respond.  There were 261 dead with 129 out of 248 Gazans being civilians, if that is possible, for most are part of a fighting force.  1,042 housing and commercial units in Gaza were damaged.  Israel hit 1,500 targets in response.  This all started over some argument over housing on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem.  

    The cease-fire was on a Thursday, May 21, 2011.  At 2 a.m. local time, just as the cease-fire took effect, life returned to the streets of Gaza. People went out of their homes, some shouting “Allahu Akbar" or whistling from balconies. Many fired in the air, celebrating the truce.                       

    President Barack Obama  of USA's last days were in the end of January 2017.  In Barack Obama's final actions in office before the inauguration of President Donald Trump, he released $221 million to the Palestinian Authority PA.  The money came from federal aid the US provides to the West Bank and Gaza, aid that totaled about $355 million in 2015. The sum released by Obama during his last hours in office had been held up by a group in Congress that included Reps. Ed Royce of California and Kay Granger of Texas.  Congress had been looking at various behaviors from Palestine — unilateral attempts at statehood, corruption, incitement of violence, and paying salaries to people in jail for terrorism — and that's why the hold has been there," Dr. Jonathan Schanzer of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies told Business Insider.  However, the payment itself has been frozen by the State Department under President Trump.    

    The news on January 20, 2021, said that the Biden administration on Wednesday unfroze $27.4 billion in government funding that former President Trump locked up before leaving office. Last Thursday, Trump used a budgetary legal provision calling on Congress to rescind funds from 73 programs that were fully funded in December's $2.3 trillion omnibus spending bill. Trump signed the bill into law but complained about many of its provisions.  It was on January 20, 2021 that Trump left office and Biden took over.  We have seen in the past that the Palestinians spend their money on ammunition to use against Israel instead of using it to make a better life for their people.  How will they use this big sum of money?  

                                                                   

    In January 18th and 20th, 2021, 3 rockets were fired from Gaza into Israel.  

    In April, 15, 23, 24, and 25th,  a total of 44 were fired of which 6 were intercepted by Israel's iron Dome defense system on the 23rd when 36 were shot at Israel.  No property was damaged.  The military responded with military strikes.  It is very upsetting to go through such an ordeal and affects everyone and everything. It cannot be laughed off.  That's why Israel must respond.  Now, you may think differently, but Israel has tried the other way of ignoring, and it only shows a weakness and more rockets as a result.                                                        

                                 Rockets hit Israel as militants killed.  

    Palestinian militants in Gaza have fired dozens of rockets at Israel after its air strikes killed top commanders and felled another tower block there.  The escalation, which began on Monday, has triggered street violence in Israel between Jews and Israeli Arabs.  In two incidents, a Jewish man in Acre was attacked by Arab men, and a Jewish mob pulled a Palestinian out of his car and beat him up in Bat Yam.  At least 67 people in Gaza and seven people in Israel have been killed.  The fighting erupted on Monday after weeks of rising Israeli-Palestinian tension in East Jerusalem which culminated in clashes at a holy site revered by Muslims and Jews.

    Between 10-18 May of 2021, during the 2021 Israel–Palestine crisis, more than 3,440 rockets were fired toward Sderot, Ashkelon, Ashdod, Jerusalem and other communities. Ten Israelis were killed. More than 90% of the rockets heading toward populated areas were intercepted by the Iron Dome. About a third fell inside the Gaza Strip. Most of the others fell in open fields.

    By 21 May, when a ceasefire came into effect, at least 4,000 rockets had been fired from the Gaza Strip towards Israel, of which hundreds fell short and hit Gaza.




    On 16 June 2021, incendiary balloons were launched from Gaza into Israel, which the Israeli Air Force responded to with multiple airstrikes in the Gaza Strip, causing fighting to resume.  The Israeli military said it targeted compounds belonging to Hamas, the militant group that controls Gaza.

    The incendiary balloons sparked 20 fires in southern Israel on Tuesday.

    Hamas said they were a response to a march by Israeli nationalists in "occupied" East Jerusalem.  Palestinians do not accept the fact that it is now part of Israel, unified with west Jerusalem.  Unfortunately, they usually call ALL of Israel as occupied land.  

    There were no casualties on either side and calm had been restored by Wednesday morning.

     

     This is a case of giving up land to the Palestinians who used it to fire rockets into Israel almost every day since they received it. More Palestinians get killed in the process because this brings on Israel's air force.   Israel does not use its people but protects their lives with bomb shelters, whereas the Palestinians are definitely using theirs in order to bring on accusation against Israel for defending their population.  Anything to put Israel in a bad light.  They are creating propaganda to use against Israel.  

    Resource:

    The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia

    Facts About Israel-Division of Information, Ministry for foreign affairs, Jerusalem

    https://www.adl.org/resources/glossary-terms/disengagement

    https://www.myjewishlearning.com/article/gaza-disengagement/

    https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/elections/.premium.HIGHLIGHT-11-days-4-340-rockets-and-261-dead-the-israel-gaza-fighting-in-numbers-1.9836041

    https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/israel-unleashes-strikes-vowing-press-gaza-77796552

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_Israel%E2%80%93Palestine_crisis

    https://www.businessinsider.com/obama-queitly-sends-221-million-to-palestine-2017-1

    https://thehill.com/policy/finance/535155-biden-reverses-trumps-freeze-on-274-billion-in-funds

    https://www.timesofisrael.com/rocket-warning-sirens-sound-near-gaza-border-idf-investigating/

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Palestinian_rocket_attacks_on_Israel_in_2021



    Wednesday, December 17, 2014

    Cont'd Refuting Noam Chomsky's Interview Part II Covering Occupation

    Nadene Goldfoot                                                                     
    Dov Weissglas in 1965, age 19

    Can you imagine people finding fault with Israel as their vocation finding  fault with them in leaving Gaza?  Noam Chomsky has done just that.

    The idea of Israel getting out of Gaza came from PM Sharon'.   "In his book Sharon: The Life of a Leader, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon's son,  Gilad,  wrote that he gave his father the idea of the disengagement. Sharon had originally dubbed his unilateral disengagement plan, the "separation plan" orTokhnit HaHafrada before realizing that, "separation sounded bad, particularly in English, because it evoked apartheid."


    Sharon suggested his disengagement plan for the first time on December 18, 2003 at the Fourth Herzliya Conference. In his address to the Conference, Sharon stated that  ″settlements which will be relocated are those which will not be included in the territory of the State of Israel in the framework of any possible future permanent agreement. At the same time, in the framework of the Disengagement Plan, Israel will strengthen its control over those same areas in the Land of Israel which will constitute an inseparable part of the State of Israel in any future agreement"

    Noam has attacked Dov Weissglas, friend of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon over the 2005 Israeli withdrawal from Gaza after gaining it in 1967's Six Day War. Previously, Egypt controlled Gaza.   Only Noam Chomsky could find fault with this.  It's when Israel left their villages, towns and cities in Gaza and withdrew in the name of PEACE.  They no longer OCCUPIED GAZA.  They left, even the greenhouses that they had built, a business that the Palestinians could walk right in and take over.  Did they?  No, they destroyed them, every one.  According to Noam, Weissglas explained to the Israeli Press  that "the goal of this disengagement-was the freezing of the peace process so as to Prevent the establishment of a Palestinian state." 

    Quite the opposite of Chomsky's accusation is the truth.  Actually, Dov Weissglas, lawyer and businessman then 58 years old, linked in the peace process as Sharon's office manager and bureau chief and was negotiating with Condoleezza Rice and Colin Powell, Secretary of State then, was the public face for Sharon.   The Israeli Left (ah yes, we have them, too "Peace Now")  has criticized him when he evidently was against this disengagement, which many now hold up as a huge mistake.
    He said it even stronger:in 2004:  The disengagement strategy with Palestinian government is actually formaldehyde (not freezing).  It supplies the amount of formaldehyde that's necessary so that there will not be a political process with the Palestinians."

    What are the properties of formaldehyde?   Preservation and disinfectant.  History of the past 10 years shows that he was right all along about  political process which turns out to be Hamas bent on Israel's destruction.    In the original Hebrew, he meant preserving peace, thinking that they would become peaceful knowing that Jews left and that some political belief would not change this.  As a linguist, Noam should know better!  Instead, he added to the misunderstanding of language by saying that Weissglas was ensuring that diplomacy "has been removed indefinitely from our agenda."   
    Gaza before Operation Protective Edge
    Ha!  Somebody introduced the new idea of voting which can be covered up without the freedom of having honest watchdogs.  Wasn't that from Obama's influence?   Just like Assad in Syria winning by 88.7%-a landslide!  

    Then he throws in historian Idith Zertal and Akiva Eldar, who are authors of "Lords of the Land-
    The War Over Israel’s Settlements in the Occupied Territories, 1967-2007", referring to Jewish settlers with the innuendo of the territories being occupied, which has become a dirty word.  .    By the way, I do not use the term, "settlers".  This is like calling San Franciscans "pioneers."  It's a political way of calling them newcomers, strangers to the land.  Their homes are not in settlements now but in villages, towns or even cities.  Better to call us "RETURNEES."  After all, Judea and Samaria were the homes of our ancestors.  Occupied?  

    The two ladies discuss The Green Line which divides land.  One side they say is The West Bank, another term I don't use.  (Note, term usage tells what side of the line you are on, left or right)  "It is also curious, especially considering the authors’ leftist perspective, that the Palestinians barely feature in their book, other than as passive victims of rapacious (excessive grasping or covetousness)  Zionist settlers and expansionist Israeli governments. "   Most of the Jewish  people living in Judea and Samaria are Jewish historians themselves deeply into our ancient history who realize the importance of this land.  They are good and religious people.  Israel is NOT expansionistic.  They are just trying to hold onto what they have. 
                                                                        
    King Abdullah of Transjordan

     Why don't you blame G-d for helping Israel to win the 1967 war that enabled them to legally gain the land the coveting King Abdullah wanted for his own and lost?  Israel didn't start the 1967 war.  But they finished it, didn't they!  

    From Nasser on May 26, 1967:  "The Arab people wants to fight.  We have been waiting for the right day when we would be fully prepared..Recently, we have felt strong enough to triumph, with God's help, if we enter into battle with Israel.  On that basis, we have decided to take the actual measures.  Taking this step makes it imperative that we be ready to embark on a total war with Israel.   " Each leader said about the same things, some stronger than others.  

      Judea and Samaria were renamed by Jordan who stole the land illegally which no international lawyer except those speaking up for Israel has ever called them on.  Who has wanted to argue with King Abdullah?  It was 80% of the Jewish Homeland!  Israel gained it back legally from the results of the 1967 war by winning.  I call it the original name of Judea and Samaria, and Samaria was an updated name for Israel, by the way.  

    In their book about the Lords, and of course they are knocking the reasons for the disengagement, they say "the ruined territory"---an innuendo that is laughable!  The land was improved upon, not ruined by the Jews.  It has been the Arabs all along who have ruined Palestine-all of it.  Read  Mark Twain's THE INNOCENTS ABROAD.  Throughout the book you will read about the wasteland, the swamps, mosquitoes, weeds he found in 1867 before the return of Russian Jews in the 1st Aliyah.  That's what the Jews had to face and change.  He noted that Palestine was only from 40 to 60 miles wide and that Missouri could be split into 3 Palestines and there would then be enough material left for part of another, possibly a whole one.  And from this Israel got a piece of the pie that is at the smallest width about 6 miles wide; so small that people in a train are told to not put their arm out the window or it would be in Palestine.  
                                                                                
    IDF of Israel, 1967 in Jerusalem

    "THE IDEA THAT Judea, Samaria and Gaza are under Israel's "occupation" was born on June 6-7, 1967, when the Israel Defense Forces overran and repossessed these territories in the Six-Day War and the National Unity Government headed by Levi Eshkol instantly applied Article 43 of the Hague Regulations to keep the existing laws in force." 1  Israel has since given the reigns over to Abbas of Fatah (formerly the PLO) who has called himself  President of Palestine since January 15, 2005.  Of course we all know that Hamas terrorists won an election and kicked Abbas out of Gaza and into Judea and Samaria.  "THE TERM "OCCUPATION", DEFINED IN ARTICLE 42 of the Hague Regulations, refers to territory that is "actually placed under the authority of the hostile army and the occupation extends only to the territory where such authority has been established and can be exercised."  Howard Grief's opinion is that  to end the myth of Israeli "occupation", the Israeli government must abolish the military regime adopted in June 1967 for Judea, Samaria and Gaza, and replace the existing military laws and regulations with the law of the State of Israel.  This international lawyer goes on to say that:  "The Jews of Judea and Samaria would, in fact and in law, be well within their constitutional rights to remain living in those territories under the most significant law of the State of Israel, the Law of Return, that enshrines in its provisions the two-thousand-year-old Jewish Right of Return and, assuming Government abandonment, to take the necessary steps to govern themselves in an independent State of Judea and Samaria."  

    The discussion of occupation is moot since "After Hamas unexpectedly won the 2006 Palestinian legislative elections and overtook the Gaza Strip, it forced out all remnants of Palestinian President Abbas’s Fatah party. Since then, Fatah has largely been in charge of the West Bank and Hamas of the Gaza Strip. Fatah remains the Palestinian Authority’s largest political and military power, but its ties to terrorist activities cause strains between Israel and the Palestinians. In fact, the issue of uniting Hamas and Fatah has been up for debate – among Palestinians and externally - since 2007. Each side wants to keep their own land and control but acknowledges that political division within the Palestinian infrastructure is probably untenable. The de facto alliance between Israel and the PA aimed to prevent Hamas from overtaking the West Bank has been US-assisted. The US created the Security U.S. Coordinator’s Office that trains Palestinian security forces and organizes Israel-PA cooperation.  Israel has been out of the picture except to be able to ensure that the Arabs do not have access to weapons to use on Israel.  They kept this part of the deal.

    The authors Zertal and Eldar say, according to Noam, that Israel left behind scorched earth, devastated services and people with neither a present nor a future.  This bald lie doesn't begin to tell the story of Jewish people forced by their government who is trying to create a reason for peace with the Palestinians to pick up and leave their homes and businesses.  It was a huge undertaking. Then, they knew their goose was cooked when it was reported back that the Palestinian Arabs completely destroyed all the greenhouses left for their use.  Scorched earth?  No way, but they did dig up their cemetery so that their loved ones would go with them, as Jacob's body was handled by his descendants.  Services?  What?  Electric and water that they thought childishly were free?  They want land; well, that means supplying their own services.  Did they think that they could kick out the Jews and that they would still maintain services for them?  Dream on.  As for their present and future, that is up to them now.  They voted in Hamas.  They had tons of help in this area from Israel.  My book of "facts about israel" put out by 1973's division of Information, Ministry for Foreign Affairs, Jerusalem, lists all the services and programs that were going on for them by Israel.  You know the old adage, you can't eat your cake and have it, too.  This is what happens from not being peaceful neighbors and instead spending all your time trying to kill them.  They act like the children who killed their parents and then cried to the judge that they were orphans now.  

    Israel's peace initiative of leaving Gaza is criticized by saying that the settlement were destroyed in an ungenerous move  by an unenlightened occupier, which in fact continues to control the territory and to kill and harass its inhabitants by means of its formidable military might.  So this is how our critics see the pain of these families in leaving.  I can only shake my head and grab an aspirin at this point.  Do I have to defend Israel more, point by point in this?  If one does not understand by now with careful reading, there is no hope for the reader. Noam calls the writers "the most respected Israeli source."  I feel he over-exaggerates.   I've never heard of Zertal and Eldar.  Neither has my good friend, the eminent Professor and historian, Victor Sharpe, a prolific writer himself.  

    "As of 1973, the status of the administered areas had not changed since June 1967.  Pending a peace settlement in which the borders between Israel and its neighbors will be decided, it is that of territories occupied during a war.  Israel has not annexed any part of the areas.  East Jerusalem was reunified in June 1967 with West Jerusalem.  


    Fatah-Hamas Unity Government: usually both are on the outs with each other
      2014: Fatah and Hamas sign a reconcilliation agreement (they have fought continually with each other over power) in April and form a unity government, on June 2 Abbas swears in the new government. Nothing has been signed with Israel.  Is East Jerusalem now considered by the Arabs as being part of this government?  How would you like to have part of Washington DC belonging to  North Korea?

    Resource:  http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dov_Weissglass
    http://rt.com/news/163696-assad-win-president-syria/
    http://www.nytimes.com/2007/10/14/books/review/LeBor-t.html?_r=0
    http://www.think-israel.org/grief.occupation.html 1
    http://www.think-israel.org/grief.consequencesabandonningjudeasamaria.html
    http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Terrorism/Fatah.html