Showing posts with label dna testing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dna testing. Show all posts

Sunday, April 21, 2019

How The Turks Got Into Palestine and How Jews Got Into Turkey:

Nadene Goldfoot                           

70 CE Occupying Romans destroyed Jerusalem, burned Temple down, Jews banned from area.  They were taken as slaves to Rome while some got away to Spain  Thus was creation of Ashkenazim and Sephardim.  Those that found refuge nearby became the Mizrachim.  
624: Muhammad broke with his Jewish supporters because they refused to recognize him as a prophet and adopt Islam. He chose now to emphasize the Arabness of the new religion and has his followers face Mecca when praying instead of Jerusalem.  Jews were either banished or executed.
634-644: Umar (c. 591-644) reigns as the second caliph. The Muslims subjugate Egypt, Palestine, Syria, Mesopotamia and Persia. Garrisons established in the conquered lands

Fighting each other was the rule beyond the Middle East after Rome had appeared on the scene in Palestine.  One reason was trading privileges.  An influx of Turks added to the number of petty principalities.  A stream of Turks started moving toward Baghdad in 830 and grew by the middle of the century, and some started kingdoms of their own.  The Saljuqs were one of 2 important groups.  The other was the Ghaznavids from 892 to 1186 whose king Mahmoud brought Islam to northern India.   They were all spreading their religion with their swords.                                                       
Saljuqs started as nomadic horse people of Central Asia

The Saljuqs got to the Middle East around the year 1000..  I'm interested in them because DNA shows that my Jewish father's line is QBZ67-discovered after my brother's Y haplogroup test of 111 alleles.   This theory would appeal to my daughter who handled a Palomino stallion beautifully when a teenager.  She was a terrific rider.                                                     


We Jews with this line make up 5% of the Jewish population. We are part of the Y2200 group reported about on familytreedna( Immediately above Q-Y2232 is Q-Y2200. It is unclear right now how and when those who are Q-Y2200 but not Q-Y2232 are related to their Ashkenazi Jewish cousins. ) Other people with Q, our very distant relatives, are found to be people like the Pashtuns, Saudis, etc, Muslims in the Middle East.  Q's origins were Mongolia, Siberia AND PARTS OF TURKEY! That goes back 32,000 years ago when the line was in Mongolia and Siberia. "Approximately 2% (10/523: 9 Q*, 1 Q-M25) of males in Turkey belong to haplogroup Q. In a study (Gokcumen 2008), it was found that among Turks who belong to the Afshar tribe (one of Oghuz Turks) haplogroup Q-M242 is seen with a prevalence of 13%."  Could this line of Turks who wound up in Syria be our relations?   Q's have been found in a city now a part of Iraq, Ur, which was the homeland of Abraham and his father, Terah.  My theory is that we were Saljuqs who teamed up with Jews in Ur along with Abraham back in c1948 BCE.  I bet that my ancestor was the butcher of the group of men and showed Abraham a trick or two in treating the cow kindly.  Or, my ancestor teamed up with the Jews as slaves in Egypt and knew Aaron.  Egypt took in slaves for workers, and could have taken some soon to be called Saljuqs.  Or, my ancestor could have been in Aleppo already, near Jerusalem and married into the family of Jews because of their beautiful daughter  in about 1115. 

Update: 4/25/19 After researching Q's in Turkey, it doesn't look feasable that we could have been from the Saljuqs.  Q's just do not show up enough with this group. https://yhaplogroups.wordpress.com/2015/01/12/y-dna-haplogroups-in-turks/ 

As for the Saljuqs who have been moving westward, they had a leader who brought them as far as Baghdad by 1055, had become the commander in chief of the caliph in Baghdad.  His people eventually separated into 3 kingdoms.  One kingdom was headed by the Saljuqs of Iran from 1037 to 1194.  They made Maragheh their capital in northern Iran.  Another was headed by the Saljuqs of Syria from 1094 to 1117 and their capital was Aleppo in northern Syria.  Aleppo also became a big business center later on, and was the home of many of the Jews living in Syria.  The 3rd group was headed by the Saljuqs of Asia Minor from 1071 to 1209 with their capital being Konya in central Turkey.  The Saljuqs of Syria and Turks in other Turkish kingdoms, became Arabized and used the Arabic language.  The Asia Minor group kept the Turkish language and the Iranian group became Persianized and spoke Persian in their courts.  
                                                       

The Turks knew how to govern.  A number of books were written to teach the princes the art of governing.  They are referred to as "PRACTICAL PRECEPTS or MIRRORS TO PRINCES.  One of the most important books was written for the Saljuqs in about 1092 and was Siyasatnameh.  They were influential in teaching Muslim political philosophy which is NOT Greek nor Islamic. 

The Saljuqs  had become an orthodox Muslim group.  They didn't abide by these practical precepts, feeling they went against their religious viewpoints.  The secularization of Islam was started by Farabi  and Avicenna on a philosophical level.  Muslims thought philosophy was a FOREIGN SCIENCE.  I don't believe that many of our rabbis thought much of it, either.  Philosophy presented a challenge to Islamic theology.  The problem was that many of these new Muslims back then were brought up with Greek philosophy.  Orthodox Islam thought many of these ideas were heretical.  

The Saljuqs being orthodox believed that Prophecy was a gift from G-d brought on by revelation.  The Salijgs were leaders of Muslims against the "heretical ideas.  The Shafi'is started schools like those of the Ismailis.  Nizam al-Mulk, the grand vazir of the Saljuqs and most effective champion of orthodox theologians, put orthodox civil administrators in all departments of the government.  These Muslim bureaucrats were in a great position to use the Muslim Shari'a to every aspect of the parts of government and society.  It was for his activities in the cause of Sunni orthodoxy that Nizam al-Mulk was murdered by an agent of the ASSASSINS, WHO BELONGED TO THE ISMAILI SECT.  
                                             

The orthodox had their hands tied by their belief system.  They could not get rid of the influence of the philosophers or the realities of the situation they were in.  Nizam al Mulk had even used a non-Muslim Persian traditions and ethics in his book.  Ghazah was teaching in the Nizamiya college in Baghdad at the time of the Saljuqas.  He tried to keep the unity of the ummah intact and had said that piety was the only qualification for the office of the caliphate.  As a result, power could legitimately be put in the hands of the sultan (governor), who ruled for the caliph (religious successor of Mohammad) .  The caliph's name is mentioned in Friday prayers and is engraved on coins and has insured the unity of the ummah (the world community of Muslims).  

The new Muslims were designing prayer buildings and copied some ideas from the Jews for their architectural needs.  They needed a high place so the muezzin could call people to prayer.  They built a tall circular or square column that was attached to their mosque.  These were called minarets, from the Hebrew word, Minorah.  
                                                         
Baghdad, perfect location:  On the Silk Road
Baghdad was going through a creative period as their caliphs were more lenient.  It is doubtful whether a strong caliphate would have allowed such creativity.  After the Saljuqs restored the power of orthodoxy and Ghazali wrote his book, scholarship and creativity began to die.  The MIDDLE AGES of the MIDDLE EAST started with the restoration of the power of orthodox Islam.  Its Renaissance started during the 1st decades of the 20th century and a Reformation has not yet happened.  

The Saljuqs and the other Turkish tribes who had the power over the Arabs, came as devout Muslims and helped to strengthen orthodoxy and the unit of the ummah under the caliph of Allah.  Every time they had a victory in fighting, they thought that Allah was with them and they felt more and more invincible.  They never gave up trying to take control over Asia Minor.
                                                    

On August 26, 1071 the Saljuqs defeated the Byzantine army in the battle of Manzikert in today's Turkey and created their kingdom in Asia Minor.  They held high hopes.  Because that Muhammad  had proclaimed Islam as the last religion, the Islamic Empire under the Caliph would be the 1st to bring the whole world under the aegis of Allah and his Prophet, they thought. "This led to the mass movement of Turks into central Anatolia—by 1080, an area of 78,000 square kilometres (30,000 sq mi) had been gained by the Seljuk Turks. It took three decades of internal strife before Alexius I(1081 to 1118) restored stability to Byzantium. Historian Thomas Asbridge says: "In 1071, the Saljuqs crushed an imperial army at the Battle of Manzikert (in eastern Asia Minor), and though historians no longer consider this to have been an utterly cataclysmic reversal for the Greeks, it still was a stinging setback." It was the first time in history a Byzantine Emperor had become the prisoner of a Muslim commander."

Muslims do not see things with a Western mind.  To them, empire, religion and culture are one.  This is where Israel has problems.  Muslims must see Israel, as little as it is, as an expanding Western empire with a different religion and culture invading their own.  The wars of expansion were ordered for Allah;  and the soldiers were fighting for His cause according to the Muslim viewpoint.  
                                                                                                                
Saladin 1137 – 4 March 1193), was the first sultan of Egypt and Syria and was Kurdish

In the days of the Crusaders, the continuous battle between the Sunni Saljuqs of Syria and the Shi'a Fatimids of Egypt had made it very dangerous for Christian pilgrims to visit the holy places in Palestine.  Saladin came on the scene by capturing Cairo, Egypt and put an end to the Fatimid rule there.  He was a good Sunni and stopped mentioning the Fatimid caliph's name in prayers and substituted the name of the Abbasid caliph, instead, who probably didn't know Saladin even existed and cared even less.  
                                                         

During the fighting against the Crusaders of Europe, the Saljuqs of Syria kept asking for the aid of their kinsmen, the Saljuqs of Iran, but their pleas fell on deaf ears.  So, when both the Iranians and the Turks in the east were attacked by the Mongols, the powers in the Fertile Crescent would not come to their aid. 
It shows that though both groups were Muslims, this makes no more difference in the Muslim world than it does elsewhere among different nations that have the same religion. 

 I see it happening with the Jews of Israel and the Jews of the USA.  The American President Trump is showing more concern for Israel than a goodly majority of the Democratic Jews who belong to a group called "J Street" which says it backs Israel but it truth is not. The Republicans have shown backing Israel more than the Democrats, who walked out on Israel's Prime Minister Netanyahu's speech at the UN during the Obama administration.  

However, whenever ALL the Muslim nations get the opportunity to attack Israel, they have done so since the battle of Israel's inception, their war of Independence 1947-49; The Sinai War of 29 October-5 November 1956;  The Six-Day War from 5 to 11 June 1967, War of Attrition from 1968-7-8 August 1970; The Yom Kippur War of 1973, , etc.  1982 . They've come from near and far to fight against Israel.  They back a Palestinian State even though they are the ones shelling out the money to the Palestinians constantly.  
                                                         
From the looks of this map, Christianity was also trying to make inroads into Asia Minor.  "Asian Christians endured the greatest persecutions. They mounted global ventures in missionary expansion the West could not match until after the thirteenth century." On the right is Syria and below it
lies Palestine who did not suffer this name until after 135 when  the Jewish general, Aluf Bar Kokhba,  lost his 3 year holding of Jerusalem, having had angered the Romans terribly by fending them off for 3 whole years. 

Turks have been the best fighters of the Middle East.  They've been an advance guard for Islam.  They won the battle of Manzikert north of Lake Van in Armenia and took the Emperor Diogenes prisoner in 1071.  This opened Asia Minor to Muslim settlement and allowed Turkish tribesmen to ride further west as far as to Smyrna.  The Salijuq Turks who had done this were eventually separated from their kinsmen in Iran and organized the Saljuqs of Asia Minor.  By warring, the Saljiuqs occupied most of Asia Minor and ruled in reality or in name until 1302. Their capital was in Konya (Iconeum)." After its conquest by Turkish tribes, Konya became the capital of the Seljuk Sultanate of Rum (Anatolia) (1077–1308) and the Karamanids (13th century–1487)." The most important change during 300 years of Saljuq rule was the Turkification of a large segment of Asia Minor.                                                      

  The Ottoman Empire lasted for 400 years ending in 1917 as they had chosen the German side, the Axis, to fight with against the Allies.  The empire had started in 1517.  The Seljuks of Asia Minor were the only Turks that continued to speak Turkish
and became the forerunners of the Ottoman Turks.   Jews were already living there as a synagogue was authorized in Brusa, the old capital, in 1326.  When Salonica was captured in 1430 by the Turks, it was populated by many Jews.  Jews were living in Constantinople also in 1453.  After the fateful date of 1492, when Columbus sailed the ocean blue and the Spanish Inquisition was full blown, the Ottoman Empire generously offered the refugees from Spain refuge.   Portugal followed suit.  The Jews were favored as valuable trading and artisan assets.  They were also a counterbalance  to the potentially disloyal Christian minorities.  Flourishing were the communities of Istanbul : Constantinople, Adrianople, Smyrna (Izmir) and especially Salonica where the intellectual traditions of Sephardi Jewry were centered.  
                                                                    
Joseph Nasi 

Palestine was from 1517, part of the Turkish Empire, as were Egypt, the Yemen, Iraq, etc.  The sultans applied the normal Moslem code against the Jews but not strictly. They were 2nd class citizens, Dhimmis.   So, persons such as Joseph NASI and Solomon ASHKENAZI were able to influence the state greatly.  Dom Joseph Nasi was a Portuguese Sephardi diplomat and administrator, member of the House of Mendes/Benveniste, nephew of Dona Gracia Mendes Nasi, and an influential figure in the Ottoman Empire during the rules of both Sultan Suleiman I and his son... 

After the 16th century, circumstances were not so good. Anti-Jewish restrictions were applied more rigidly, but there was no general reaction  Even the false messiah of SHABBETAI TZEVI, a man that could have brought on charges of disloyalty, didn't undermine the position of Turkish Jewry, but the outcome weakened it spiritually.  Down to the 19th century, the community's position remained unchanged, but its treatment no longer seemed enlightened as compared with other countries.  

It was the 3rd largest Jewish community in the world after Russia and Austro-Hungary, numbering 350,000 in 1900.  The gradual disintegration of the Turkish Empire brought numbers of its Jewish population living in the Balkans, etc, under other authorities with changes generally being worse.  

This came to a head with the 1st Balkan War and WWI when the Ottoman (Turkish) Empire destroyed itself.  It's now just Turkey.  Turkey had to re-organize itself along nationalistic lines.  Exchanges of populations were made with Greece.  The position of Jewish Turks were no longer the favored minority  with some discrimination happening to them.  37,000 Jews emigrated to Israel after 1948.  There were 20,000 Jews in Turkey in 1990 with 18,000 living in Istanbul, 1,500 in Izmir, and smaller communities in the cities of Edime, Brusa, and Ankara.  The spiritual, cultural distinctions for former days has come to an end.  

Fighting in Turkey continued as in 2016 in Istanbul, the Turkish military attempted a coup against the president Erdogen, who has also become very Orthodox in his religious viewpoints, causing him to be quite nasty to Israel.  

Reference: Textbook, MIDDLE EAST Past & Present, by Yahya Armajani, Thomas M. Ricks
https://www.familytreedna.com/groups/jewish-q/about/background
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Manzikert
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Konya
https://www.christianity.com/church/church-history/timeline/1-300/asian-christianity-11629575.html
http://www.thelatinlibrary.com/imperialism/notes/islamchron.html
The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haplogroup_Q-M242
https://jewishbubba.blogspot.com/2017/02/the-jews-of-turkey.html



Sunday, July 30, 2017

Getting the Most Out of Our 46 Chromosomes

Nadene Goldfoot                                          
     
We have 46 chromosomes in 23 pairs;  23 from Mom and 23 from Dad.  If they are related somewhat, we get a double dose of our inheritance in certain areas.  Most people's parents are not related, however,  so we get quite a variety.  GedMatch.com can tell you if you parents were related.  On these chromosomes are about 30,000 genes.  By 2005,  scientists didn't know the the functions for over 50% of identified genes.  Family Tree DNA shows you if your match is on your mother's side or your father's side or both.

Finally, I've discovered that geneticists know quite a bit about what each of our chromosomes does for us.  We who pursue DNA testing in finding people who match our set of chromosomes have always wondered what our new cousin shares with us besides the segments on some of our chromosomes.  Are we sharing hair color?  Love of art?  What?  The DNA testing company, 23&Me can tell you certain aspects such as taste that you share, but I haven't seen this in other companies.
                                                                   
DNA is in the shape of a  double helix,
2 spirals held together by pairs of nucleotides or base pairs
Sara Gottfried, M.D. has written the book, YOUNGER, which is a breakthrough program to reset your genes and reverse aging by turning back the clock 10 years.  It all has to do with what we eat.
She's a Harvard and MIT physician and scientist.

"After graduating from the physician-scientist training program at Harvard Medical School and MIT, Dr. Gottfried completed her residency at the University of California at San Francisco, where she still serves on the faculty. She is board-certified in Obstetrics and Gynecology, a teacher of the adjunct faculty at Touro University College of Osteopathic Medicine, and a mentor to medical students in her integrative medicine practice, The Gottfried Center for Organic "  She has books about our hormones as well.  

Gynecology. https://www.youtube.com/user/DrGottfried.

I've had suspicions about this but now it's a proven fact.  Mothers affect their future babies by what they are eating during pregnancy.  I suppose that's why doctors prescribe a lot of vitamins for us during this period.  Our genes are controlled by on and off switches, and what we eat controls them.
                                                                           
I've discovered from this book that fasting periodically is good for our bodies.  It gives it a chance to retool and get certain elements functioning much better.  Our body needs this break.  There is such a thing as a fat gene.  If we're born with it, we still have a fighting chance not to be forever fat by how and what we eat.  Alzheimer's can be prevented by what we eat.  There is a gene for controlling our appetite!  I've always felt that my appistat (control of appetite) wasn't working.  I'd never feel full like other people say they are.

We grandmas also realize that how we feel about being pregnant can also affect the minds of their children.  Those babies who were wanted seem to turn out much better and are happier people.  Whether or not you nurse your baby affects that baby, and nursing is the best to do.  Actually, this is why in the past, women had babies every two years.  They nursed one baby for 2 years, keeping them unable to conceive again.  If they quit nursing, oh oh, there was a sibling born the next year!  

Being my father was a meat dealer with his own business, we were blessed to have lots of beef in the kitchen.  I'd have a boyfriend over for dinner and Mom would be serving T bone steaks.  I was the kid that complained about it, saying, "Why can't we have hot dogs for dinner like other folk?"  Living in the Pacific Northwest, we did have salmon about once a week, but today it costs a fortune to buy.  So does beef, for that matter.  However, according to this new research, we should be eating fish more and beef much less and not as  the star of the meal.  Here's where poor people have the advantage of dining on beans.  That's a healthy choice!
                                                                       

Scientists are even giving these identified genes weird names.  Where they are on the tape measure of cMs, I have no idea, so it still doesn't tell me what Noah and I share in our matching of 100cMs total.  However, it is interesting how they are identifying certain qualities on these chromosomes.
                                                               
Our 23 sets of chromosomes
On the right is a chromosome painting as it comes up showing us how we match with another person.  A match on the 23rd indicates  females matching.  
Chromosome #1 has the most known genes (2,968), and the 23rd or Y chromosome -sex chromosome determining sex has the fewest (231).

An example of what some chromosomes contain is:
                                                                     
#1 chromosome:  (MTHFR) Methylation, intelligence, tissue replacing, bad odors, youth
(MTOR) which is longevity.  Fasting turns this gene off when hyperactive, associated with Alzheimers and cancer

#3  Regulation of appetite, night vision, preventing Aids

#4  Clock gene, controlling our fast or slow aging, , fingerprints and early mortality

#6  (Fox 03) Longevity turned on in a 20 minute Sauna, controlling muscle development, immunity

#10 (SIRT) longevity, fasting intermittently is good for us.

#12 (Gene VDR) Vitamin D receptor ...some of us need more of D than other people

#13  (Gene BRCAL BRCAZ)  Breast Cancer

#16  (FTO) Fatso Gene

#17  Breast Cancer

#19 (APOB) Alzheimer's and Bad Heart Gene

Here's a look at a match between 2 people with results at GedMatch.com
We're viewing chromosome #'s 3 and #10 with segments matching from a start and a stopping point; the measurement of the segment being 10.4cMs and 8.3cMs.
Whether or not we are sharing identified genes or not is unknown.
Even knowing if we have the gene for something; are we eating so as to make it function or not?
                                                       

3
71,514,829
78,463,902
10.4

10
99,246,547
109,351,415
8.3

Largest segment = 10.4 cM
Total of segments > 7 cM = 18.7 cM

                                                                 

  What we put in our mouth can harm us or help us.  Of course, all the tasty things like chocolate cake and ice cream are NOT good for us, but they sure make living fun!
                                                                         
All this does bring to mind our kosher laws, which tells us what not to eat such as pork and camels and crabs and clams and eagles.  I can't help but wonder if there isn't a good reason for not eating these foods other than what we already understand.   The kosher symbol tells us it's kosher.
                                                                           
"The killing of the animal is hard on kosher meat packing houses as the killing cannot be done in an assembly line fashion.  The rules for this "to do according to Kosher law" are called shehitah and are in the Oral Torah.  The rules are for meat and fowls but not fish.  The cows do not see an animal being slaughtered which could cause fright "in a kosher meat packing house.    Therefore, there is hopefully no cortisol or norepeneherine (stress chemicals) found in the meat.  The animals should not experience the scent of death.  The spinal cord is sectioned which cuts off pain to the brain.  This is done to make sure there was no pain."  Evidently we were told this over 3,000 years ago of what not to do without saying if it affected our body or not but we were expected to just follow and trust in this law which Jews did.  Now we see that we ingest stress chemicals by the usual slaughter house methods if it isn't kosher.  
                                              
No glasses of milk with a meat meal, water is fine,
children have milk at other times, but not near a meat meal

Another kosher law is not to mix milk and meat or eat them at the same meal but anywhere from one to six hours are expected to separate them in eating, and the reason is not that milk products are not that good for us and meat is to be a 20% of a meal, but that eating these together is a slap in the face to the cow who birthed the calf and by eating the calf and her milk together is an insult to how she serves our food needs.  Therefore, an observant Jew has not eaten hamburgers and milkshakes as a meal.  

Resource:  YOUNGER by Sara Gottfried, MD
http://jewishbubba.blogspot.com/2014/01/differences-between-kosher-and-halal.html

Tuesday, October 23, 2012

Haifa Caves That Were Home for Neanderthals

Nadene Goldfoot
A group of 4 caves near Haifa on the western slope of Mount Carmel were found to be home for Neanderthals and early anatomically modern humans who lived there 15,000 years ago.  They lived side by side as part of the same culture.  We're going back when humans evolved over a period of 500,000 years.

The caves have evidence of burials, early stone architecture and show how man went from the hunter to the gatherer lifestyle and on to agriculture and animal raising.  They found remains of stone houses and pits which are evidence of a settlement.

It took 90 years of excavation of these sites to find all this evidence, so this must have started in about 1922.  They hope to find more information.  UNESCO says the site provides "an archive of early human life in southwest Asia."

This is now the 7th world Heritage Site in Israel, which is part of a UNESCO World Heritage Site.  It's called the Nahal Me'arot Nature Reserve.  This place provides a chronological framework when humans were developing.

Other sites are the Masada, the Old city of Akko and the White City of Tel Aviv.

Genetic studies show that modern Europeans have between 1% to  4 % of their genes from Neanderthals who died off 28,000 years ago.

Being Jewish and having the hobby of genealogy, one hits the stone wall  in trying to go back very far, and it's been hard to find information on my father's line, so I have resorted to dna testing.  Through 23& Me in California, I found out that my chromosomes showed that I had 2.9% of Neanderthal in my genes.  I was in the 93% tile of my other matches!  The average Eastern European only has 2.5%  Lucky me!  Through familytreedna in Houston, my brother was found to have the Q haplogroup of Ydna, Q1b1a to be specific or Q-L245, which looks like a mathematical equation of where we came from.  At first we were led to believe this origin was from the Khazarian Empire, which lies close to Russia.  Now with further testing, findings are showing that some of our group have the marker to be from somewhere close to Ur, which lies in today's Iraq. It's where our forefather, Abraham came from.   I'm getting closer to those caves!

There are other famous caves with remains of Neanderthal man.  One such cave is the Shanidar Cave in Iraq, of all places.  Shanidar is the name of the elder male found there.  Other caves of famous note are the La Ferrassie Caves in SW France and a cave in northern Spain, El Castillo, which goes back more than  40,800 years with a painting showing hands, and the hands must be handprints and they look exactly like ours today.  It is the oldest ever found.

Being there are many caves scattered about the world that contained Neanderthals, I'm wondering if my friend, a geneticist PhD  isn't right in his theory that man came from several sources and wasn't just from one single man.  That brings up even more questions, like how did that happen?

I can't declare that these caves were our caves of origin, though.  Our Q branch on the tree of man originally came from Siberia, Mongolia and parts of Turkey and we hooked up with Native Americans way back then who are on another Q twig.  There must be caves that held similar development in those places as well.  However, our twig  had migrated towards the Middle East and evidently settled in somewhere there just in time for all the history to start taking place, like Abraham's family's move there.  It looks like some stayed in Turkey.  Our Q twig makes up 5% of the Jewish male population of today.

I'm so glad that I lived in Haifa from 1980-1981 when I made aliyah to Israel.  It was there that I attended a 10 month long ulpan for teachers to retrain and work in Israel.  It is such a beautiful city, on the Mediterranean Sea, and reminded me a little of Portland for that reason.  At least I was able to walk to the beach and enjoy all the life there, from eating Shwarmas in the kiosks to the aromatic flowers of brilliant colors all in bloom.  I just wish I knew about those caves!  Hmmm, I wonder if my oil painting prowess isn't from my Neantherthal cousins!

Resource: Esther Hecht's article in October/November 2012 Hadassah magazine page 27.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-2210403/Neanderthals-human-lived-side-Middle-eastern-caves-interbred-research-finds.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanidar_Cave
http://www.csmonitor.com/Science/2012/0615/Cave-art-suggests-that-Neanderthals-weren-t-such-Neanderthals-after-all-video