Showing posts with label Hanukkah. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hanukkah. Show all posts

Saturday, November 5, 2022

Hanukkah, a Question of Assimilation

 Nadene Goldfoot                                             


Our 8 day celebration of Hanukkah falls on December 18th this year (Kislev 25-Tevet 3) that commemorates the victory of Judah the Maccabee over Antiochus Epiphanes and the rededication of the abused 2nd Temple and altar, an event that happened about 23 centuries ago or 2,197 years ago.  This was a war and an occupation that made the greatest difference in our belief of Judaism and whether or not it would continue.  That's why we remember it with celebration.  

 Judah died in 160 BCE and was the oldest of Mattathias the Hasmonean's sons.  They had led a revolt against the Greeks led by Antiochus Epiphanes IV in 167-166 BCE.  

Antiochus Epiphanes was a Greek king from the House of Seleucus who ruled Syria in the Hellenistic period.  There had been 13 of these kings.  The first, Antiochus III, reigned from 223 to 187 BCE and had transferred 2,000 Jewish families from Babylon to Lydia and Phrgia.  He had captured Jerusalem in 198 BCE but had treated the Jews with some understanding.

Antiochius IV Epiphanes, our man in the Hanukkah history, reigned from 175 to 163 BCE and was turned back by Rome on his 2nd expedition against Egypt in 168 BCE so he occupied Jerusalem, plundered the Temple treasure, and endeavored to Hellenize Judea by force in order to convert it into a reliable frontier province.  This is how he is involved in our history of Hannukah.  By occupying Jerusalem and ordering their new Greek laws or else, people were being assimilated;  Hellenized.  

This was too much for Judah the Maccabee who was on the right-a religious man. He was not about to let the Greeks defame their 2nd Temple.  The Jews had recently returned to Israel from their forced kidnapping and removing to Babylon Exile and had just rebuilt the Holy Temple.  They had been the subjects to the domination of imperial powers--the Persian Empire (Iran), then the conquering armies of Alexander the Great. When Alexander died, his huge kingdom was divided up among his generals.  Israel found itself under the rule   of the Seleucid Dynasty---Greek kings who reigned from Syria.  

Over the years of Greek domination, many Jews had begun to embrace the Greek culture and its hedonistic, pagan way of life.  these Jewish Hellenists became willing pawns in Antiochus' scheme to obliterate every trace of the Jewish religion and especially their belief in One G-d which went against their whole panacea of gods and half-gods in Olympus. 

The Holy Temple was invaded, desecrated and robbed of all its treasures.  Many innocent  people  were massacred, and the survivors were heavily taxed.  

Antiochus placed an idol of Zeus on the holy altar, and forced the Jews to bow before it under penalty of death.  He forbade the Jewish people to observe their most sacred traditions, such as the Sabbath, and the rite of circumcision.   Then he proclaimed himself a god, taking the name "Antiochus Epiphanes which means, the Divine.  At that point, even his own followers mocked him as Antiochus Epimanes,---the madman.  

That wasn't all.  In every city and town, altars were erected with statues of the Greek gods and goddesses.  Soldiers rounded up the Jews and forcibly compelled them to make offerings and engage in other immoral acts customary to the Greeks.  The Jews felt incapable of resistance.  

However, in a small village called Modin that was a few miles away east of Jerusalem, Mattityahu, patriarch of the priestly Hasmonean clan, stepped forward to challenge the Greek soldiers and those who acquiesced to their demands.  Backed by his 5 sons, he attacked the troops, slew the idolators, and destroyed the idol.  Their cry was "All who are with G-d, follow me!"Then he and a courageous circle of partisans retreated to the hills, where they gathered forces to overthrow the oppression of Antiochus and his soldiers.  

This turned into an army of men, now under the command of his son, Yehuda (Judah) Maccabee, which grew daily in numbers and strength.  They had on their shields the biblical slogan, "Who is like unto Thee, O G-d," and they would swoop down upon the Syrian troops under cover of darkness and scatter their enemy, then return to their encampments in the hills.  This was the first known practice of Guerilla Warfare.   Only 6,000 men, but they defeated a heavily armed battalion of 47,000 Syrians.  

Enraged, Antiochus sent an even larger army against them, and in the miraculous, decisive battle at Bet Tzur, the Jewish forces emerged victorious.  From there, they proceeded onto Jerusalem, where they liberated the city and reclaimed the Holy Temple.   They cleared the Sanctuary of the idols, rebuilt the altar, and prepared to resume the Divine Service.                     

 Our menorah on the Arch of Titus in Rome that the Romans took away in 70 CE.  Titus, commander of the forces of the Roman Empire who sacked Jerusalem and destroyed the 2nd Temple carried off the Menorah as part of the spoils of his conquest.  It was used as a symbol of his subjugation of the Jews.  The Arch seemed to be built before he returned to Rome, and the Menorah was therefore inaccurately depicted.  Notice  below is our 8-branched menorah used for Hanukkah.  

A central part of the daily service in the Temple had been the kindling of the brilliant lights of the Menorah.  Now, with the Temple about to be rededicated, only one small cruse of the pure, sacred olive oil was found.  It was only one day's supply, and they know it would take more than a week for the special process required to prepare more oil.  

The Maccabees, full of joy and thanksgiving, lit the lamps of the Menorah with the small amount of oil anyway and dedicated the Holy Temple anew .  A miracle happened in that as if in confirmation of the power of their faith, the oil did not burn out---and the flames shone brightly  for 8 full days--thus the days we celebrate.  

By the next year, our Sages officially proclaimed the festival lasting 8 days in perpetual commemoration of this victory over religious persecution.  Judaism wasn't harming anyone.  Circumcision has proven to be beneficial medically.  It was a practice started in Egypt with the pharaohs.  Judaism believed in the importance of a life.  If the religious group hadn't put a stop to this Hellenization that was going on, Jews and Christians would be behaving like the Greeks today believing in the gods of Olympus.  


Judah Maccabee was called The Hammerer.  His brothers did not fare as well later on.  The 5 were Judah the Maccabee, Jonathan, Simon, John and Eleazar.  They had held a series of raids to rescue the Jewish populations of Ammon, Idumea (Edom), Gilead, and Galilee.  They were defeated in  163 BCE at Bet Zechariah where Eleazar was killed.  The Hasmoneans were able owing to dynastic distractions in Syria, to get terms securing Jewish religious freedom, but Judah and his party, also aspiring for political freedom too, continued to fight and Judah fell at Elasa in 160 BCE.  

John was murdered shortly after that and 

Jonathan took over the leadership.  Jonathan was able to secure the  high priesthood position in 152 BCE (for Cohens only- so the family were a line of Cohens-descended from Aaron, brother of Moses).  He also became the governor of Judah in 150 BCE. 

Simon succeeded in gaining exemption from tribute by 147BCE.  He was confirmed by the people as hereditary high priest, ethnarch, and  general in 142BCE.  Then he was murdered by 135BCE.  

    His son, John Hyrcanus, succeed his father, Simon. was defeated badly by Antiochus VII Sidetes.  Jerusalem was taken by the Syrians after a prolonged siege and Judea once more became a Seleucid province.  After the defeat of Antiochus in his war against Parthia, John launched a successful offensive against Transjordan, Samaria and Idumea (Edom), marking the transition of the Hamsoneans to a semi-hellenized secular military dynasty.  

This led to his repudiation of the Pharisees and John's adherence to the aristocratic Sadducee Party.  He was succeeded by his sons, Judah Aristobulus (105-104 BCE) and Alexander Yannai (104-76 BCE) one of whom was the 1st to adopt the royal title. Yannai set up a standing mercenary army and conquered Transjordan,, Idumea, and the coastal plain.  His antagonism to the Pharisees, who opposed his war policy, led to civil war in which he was victorious after a bloody struggle, but the Pharisees were in the ascendant during the reign of his widow, Salome Alexandra (76-69 BCE).

                               Herod I (73 BCE-4 BCE).  His father, Antipater, was an Idumean (Edomite) and his mother was Cypros, a Nabatean.

I note that if we Jews weren't always in danger of assimilating into conquerors' cultures, our neighbors assimilated into ours and made their affects on us as well, like Herod who gained his own power.

 With her death, the Hasmoneans declined.  The strife between her sons, Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II led to the intervention and eventual domination of Antipater and his son Herod, with Roman assistance.  

Pompey drastically reduced the country's territory in 63 BCE.  Hyrcanus remained a puppet while the efforts of Aristobulus II and his sons, Alexander and Antigonus Mattathias to regain power failed.

    Hyrcanus' granddaughter, Mariamne, married Herod but was put to death by him in 29 BCE as were the surviving Hasmoneans in 30 BCE, and Mariamn's sons, Alexander and Aristobulus in 7 BCE.  

And so, though Judas Maccabee, the Hammerer,  thought his success was forever, died before he saw what would happen to his family line. Hellenizing did have a disastrous lingering affect. Had it not been for his bravery, though, that event stayed in his descendants' minds, and remained somehow, to fight another day to keep Judaism alive.  

Resource:

The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia

Chabad-Your Chanukah Guide, Dec 5-13, 1996, Lubavitch 

Monday, December 14, 2015

Who Is The President of Israel, Reuven Rivlin?

Nadene Goldfoot                                                              
     
We hear so much about the Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu.  Who is the president and what has he done?
                                                                             
Reuven Rivlin is the president of Israel.  He was born in Jerusalem when it was part of Mandatory Palestine because the British held the mandate then on September 9, 1939, a scary year for Jews living in Germany.  It's the year my uncle managed to get out of Germany, probably one of the last to do so.  He was elected as Israel's 10th president on June 19, 2014, so he hasn't been president very long.

Reuven was born into the Rivlin family who made aliyah to Jerusalem in 1809.  His parents were  Yosef Yoel Rivlin and Rachel "Ray" Rivlin.   Reuven  is said to be a descendant of students of the famous rabbi, the  Vilna Gaon AKA ELIJAH BEN SOLOMON ZALMAN (1720-1797) in Lithuania.  The Vilna had traveled through Poland and Germany, finally settling in Vilna, Lithuania where he taught about the Torah and had his own academy.  The Mitnaggedim regarded the Vilna as their spiritual leader.  They were against Hasidim.  Reuven  himself is a secular Jew.

His parents created the first Hebrew edition of the Koran and his father was a candidate to be the 3rd president of Israel.  Reuven received a law degree from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and has been a lawyer.  He's fluent in Arabic, and of course, Hebrew, and also in English.  He is married to Nechama Rivlin nee Shulman  and has 4 children.  Reuven  is a vegetarian and has been since the late 60's.

Reuven and MK Meir Sheetrit had to have a runoff vote in 2014 and Reuven received the support of 63 MKs.  He also won support from both Arab legislators who appreciated his courtesy, and even from right-wingers like Naftali Bennett and Danny Danon.  Danny also had the desire to make Judea and Samaria part of today's Israel proper.  (The drawback I see to this, though I would like to have the land itself as part of Israel proper, is that it would bring in as citizens more Palestinian Arabs and would upset the balance.  Israel cannot go the way of Lebanon where the Christians were assassinated who were in power.  Right now it's 6 million Jews and 1.7 million Arabs.  Israel was created to be a Jewish state and is the only one in the world.  They must watch this balance.  Today we have IS creating a caliphate out of Syria and Iraq and we don't want any part of Israel to slip into that).  

Rivlin replaced Shimon Peres as President.  By March 2015, he officially gave Netanyahu the assignment of forming a new government which followed elections the week before.
                                                                     
A terrible event happened 4 months later  in July 2015 in Duma, Judea-Samaria.  A Palestinian home was firebombed and  toddler Ali, 18 month old, was killed, and Abbas  and other Arabs immediately accused Jews of doing it.   Rivlin also joined them in thinking this.   That's because "Hebrew graffiti was sprayed nearby.  “Revenge!” was written on one wall, next to a Star of David. They all thought this was reverse terrorism done by masked Jews.   I personally think the handwriting is more from an Arab writer than a Hebrew writer.  Was this a planted attack?  

"In the aftermath of the Duma arson in July, three right-wing activists were placed under administrative detention over suspected "price tag" and other extremist activities. But based on Yaalon's comments, it appears they are unconnected to the terrorist cell in question. 
The firebombing attack on the Dawabshe family home in July killed 18-month-old Ali and fatally wounded his parents. In addition to hurling molotov cocktails, the attackers also daubed the words "Revenge" and "Long Live King Messiah" in Hebrew on the wall of the house."   

For agreeing with Assad and others in believing it was Jews who were terrorists, Rivlin received death threats.  Now it's been over 4 months since the firebombing.   "Four months later, four months during which the Shabak did its best to pin the murders on “Jewish terrorists,” they still do not have enough evidence to charge anyone with the crime. Perhaps that’s because the real arsonists weren’t Jews?  It's still hard to accept that we have Jews who would do such a thing.

Now some people are worried about Rivlin's performance at a meeting in New York being held today by the extreme-leftist newspaper, Ha'aretz and the New Israel Fund people who will be attending this conference.  Rivlin is to be a speaker.  This group supports BDS.  Those attending oppose Israeli policy and advocate American intervention in its affairs.  Saeb Erekat of the Palestinians will be there, People like friends of Arafat and partisans of the Palestinian cause will be in the audience.  Who is going to back up Rivlin?  All they will be doing is giving false testimonies of "war crimes" or bad behavior.  They have never been able to show proof or document any of the lies they spread, and their reports are nothing but propaganda, not journalism.  

When questioned about the dangers of attending such a conference, Rivlin answered that since Avner Gvaryahu of Breaking the Silence (BTS)  would be on a different panel from Rivlin, there would be no connection between them, and that he thought his appearance at the conference would be harmless.   The worry is that New York Times will quote these speakers, especially since Rivlin is there speaking, and they are all BDS backing people.  Students on campuses in the USA will go out and say, "the state of Israel is an apartheid state and commits war crimes."  90% of the speakers will be attacking Israel's policies and many are professionally engaged to demonize and deligitimize the Jewish state and that Rivlin's presence will lend legitimacy to their anti-Zionist project.  Rivlin's friends don't want him to be exploited to further an agenda that is against Israel.  
                                                                        

He just attended  a Hanukkah party at the White House. Obama opened it up.  "Barack Obama
Hello, everybody! Well, welcome to the White House, and Happy Hanukkah! Before we begin, let's give a big round of applause to our musical guests, the Maccabeats. (Applause.) This is not the first time they have performed here, but they are more popular than ever. Their latest viral video is called "Latke Recipe." (Laughter.) So if the food is better than usual this year, you will know why."   While Rivlin  was enjoying himself, Susan Talve, a reform female rabbi there made a video of progressive principles that had little to do with Hanukkah or Judaism in the name of both that was nothing but silly and pointless.  It went over like a lead balloon in Israel.  Quickly she had called for the gates of the USA to be open for all immigrants, praised the Black Lives Matter movement and groups getting guns off the streets, urged the clean up of fires of toxic nuclear wastes, identified with the Women of the Wall and denounced islamophobia, homophobia, transphobia, racism and anti-Semitism, and finally ended the video with telling everyone to do .everything to bring security for Israelis and justice for Palestinians as allies committed to a lasting peace for all peoples.  This party managed to offend both Jews and Catholics by Susan's group's attendance. They also are pushing for female Catholic priests, so her attendance was a very political statement arranged by Obama.     She said all this as a  "bizarre pre-Menorah lighting rant at the White House Chanukah party"  "Susan Talve was one of two members of the anti-Israel group T'ruah which promotes Charity BDS against Jewish groups, to be allowed to recite the invocation at the White House Chanukah party. A large number of T'ruah leaders were in attendance at the White House Chanukah party."

Rivlin replied, Insha'allah, insha'allah (if allah wills it) , and she repeated the phrase 4 more times, adding that no matter how much violence is in Paris or California, we will respond with more love, more understanding and more compassion.  Throughout the demonstration, Obama "stood with a sardonic half-smile."  "Approximately 1,800 American and Canadian rabbis are affiliated with T'ruah."

Israelis are feeling that Rivlin needs more of a highly developed political sense for his position. He may have been sandbagged.   Americans are feeling just that also about the future president to be elected of the USA.  They don't have a Prime Minister to fall back on.  Rivlin walked into doo doo at the party and didn't even see it coming.  Perhaps that was the best way such an incident could have possibly been handled, anyway.  His innocence was apparent-their BAD was noted.  

Update: 12/15/15, 1.27pm on Arabic fluency
Resource:

Rivlin's Folly:  Posted on December 13, 2015 by Vic Rosenthal-Abu Yehuda-a blog about the struggle to keep the Jewish state

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reuven_Rivlin
http://www.timesofisrael.com/tensions-soar-after-palestinian-baby-killed-in-west-bank-arson-attack/
http://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/199187#.Vm89wNIrJkg
https://www.frontpagemag.com/point/261109/obamas-chanukah-party-offended-jews-and-catholics-daniel-greenfield
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T%27ruah
http://www.jpost.com/Jewish-World/Jewish-Features/Rivlin-family-celebrates-the-birth-of-its-50000th-member