Showing posts with label Sicarii. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sicarii. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 28, 2021

Jews Taking On the Strongest Army In The World

 Nadene Goldfoot                                                  

Pompey the Great was

in the Temple of Jerusalem following the Siege of Jerusalem (63 BCE) that occurred during his campaigns in the east, and shortly after his successful conclusion of the Third Mithridatic War.  Pompey had been asked to intervene in a dispute over inheritance to the throne which turned into a war between Hyrcanus II and Aristobulus II for the throne of the Hasmonean Kingdom. His conquest of Jerusalem, however, spelled the end of Jewish independence and the incorporation of Judea as a client kingdom of the Roman Republic. 

- Image ID: W6RMN7.  He was the start of the War of the Jews and Romans.  

The Romans were a thorn in Judah's side since General Pompey entered Jerusalem in 63 BCE.  Jewish-Roman problems have festered with this prick.   100 years of Roman occupation of Judah caused the explosion.   Roman general Pompey conquered Jerusalem and its surroundings by 63 BCE. 

The Romans deposed the ruling Hasmonean dynasty of Judaea (in power from c. 140 BCE) and the Roman Senate declared Herod the Great(73 BCE-4 BCE) "King of the Jews" in c. 40 BCE. Judea proper, Samaria and Idumea became the Roman province of Iudaea in 6 CE.   Father was Antipater, the Idumean by his Nabatean wife, Cypros. He captured Jerusalem in 37 with the Roman army.  Herod taxed the Jews heavily.  Mark Antony demanded large sums from his protege.  

                                            

Under Roman rule a number of new groups, largely political, emerged in Judea. Their common aim was to seek an independent Jewish state. They were also zealous for, and strict in their observance of, the Torah.    After the death of King Herod, a political group known as the Herodians, who apparently regarded Herod as the messiah, sought to reestablish the rule of Herod’s descendants over an independent Palestine as a prerequisite for Jewish preservation. Unlike the Zealots, however, they did not refuse to pay taxes to the Romans.  Taxes would have been the least of their complaints, unless it had been a ridicuiously  outlandish expectation.  

                                                                

The Sicarii (Assassins), so-called because of the daggers (sica) they carried, arose about 54 CE, according to Josephus, as a group of bandits who kidnapped or murdered those who had found a modus vivendi with the Romans. It was they who made a stand at the fortress of Masada, near the Dead Sea, committing suicide rather than allowing themselves to be captured by the Romans (73).  They were not bandits, but family men.   Josephus wrote for the Romans.  
The Zealots, whose appearance was traditionally dated to 6 CE, were one of five groups that emerged at the outset of the first Jewish war against Rome (66–73 CE), which began when the Jews expelled the Romans from Jerusalem,.  The client king, Agrippa II, fled the city, and a revolutionary government was established. The Zealots were a mixture of bandits, insurgents from Jerusalem, and priests, who advocated egalitarianism and independence from Rome. 

In 68 the Zealots overthrew the government established by the original leaders of the revolt and took control of the Temple during the civil war that followed.  Many of them perished in the sack of Jerusalem by the Roman general (and later emperor) or in fighting after the city’s fall.   

                                                                     

 Titus (reigned 79–81) and burned down Jerusalem and the Temple in 70 CE.  The arch of Titus in Rome depicts his doing;  causing Jewish to carry the goods from the Temple all the way to Rome, where it has never been found again. 

       Rome burning in 64 CE under Emperor Nero's Rule

The Great Revolt began in the year 66 CE, during the twelfth year of the reign of Nero, said to be a mad-man, who fiddled while Rome burned.  The popular myth that "Nero fiddled while Rome burned" is not true—even in the first century CE, Rome was filled with poorly constructed slums that easily caught fire. On July 18, 64 CE, a fire started in the enormous Circus Maximus stadium in Rome, now the capital of Italy.                             

   The Great Jewish Revolt: The Siege and Destruction of Jerusalem by the Romans Under the Command of Titus, 70 CE, Oil on canvas. Painter: David Roberts, c. 1850 CE

Originating under Roman and Jewish religious tensions, the crisis escalated supposedly due to anti-taxation protests and attacks upon Roman citizens by the Jews.  The result of this revolt was in the destruction of Jewish towns, the displacement of its people and the appropriation of land for Roman military use, as well as the destruction of the Jewish Temple and polity.  Whatever made our ancestors think they could win against the Roman army, the strongest in the world?  

                                                  

This happened in Judea, called the First Jewish–Roman War (66–73 CE), sometimes called the Great Jewish Revolt (Hebrew: המרד הגדול‎ ha-Mered Ha-Gadol), or The Jewish War.  There were tensions going on between the occupying Romans and the religious Jews.  

The Jew, Jesus, who was said to be the king of the Jews, tried by the Sanhedrin, was crucified along with thousands of other Jews in 30-33 CE.  Pontius Pilate was the Roman prefect (governor) of Judaea (26–36 CE) who presided at the trial of Jesus and gave the order for his crucifixion.    "Christ was crucified on the pretext that he instigated rebellion against Rome, on a par with zealots and other political activists," the authors wrote in the report.                                

Thousands of Jews were crucified by the Romans. Their reasons were petty;  anything to rid themselves of the Jews.   Romans had been occupying Jerusalem since 66 BCE.   Apian Way was lined with the crosses.                                       

In 4 B.C E., the Roman general Varus crucified 2,000 Jews, and there were mass crucifixions during the first century CE., according to the Roman-Jewish historian Josephus.  Varus had gone to govern Syria from 7/6 BCE until 4 BC E with four legions under his command, where he was known for his harsh rule and high taxes. Publius Quinctilius Varus (46 BCE – 9 CE) was a Roman general and politician under the first Roman emperor Augustus. Varus is generally remembered for having lost three Roman legions when ambushed by Germanic tribes led by Arminius in the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest, whereupon he took his own life.    Romans were still crucifying people in 71 BCE, like Spartacus, above.  This former gladiator was one of the escaped slave leaders in the Third Servile War, a major slave uprising against the Roman Republic, which took place just after General Pompey  had attacked Judea in 66 BCE; a time of rebelling against Rome. Crucifixion had been going on over 100 years practiced by the Romans at this point in time.                                                     

       Herod the Great (73 BCE-4 BCE)  selected as king by Romans

The Jewish historian Josephus mentions the swift action of Varus against a messianic revolt in Judaea after the death of the Roman client king, Herod the Great, in 4 BC.E.  After occupying Jerusalem, he crucified 2000 Jewish rebels and may have thus been one of the prime objects of popular anti-Roman sentiment in Judaea (Josephus, who made every effort to reconcile the Jewish people to Roman rule, felt it necessary to point out how lenient this judicial massacre had been). Ha! Massacring 2,000 innocents is not trivial to the people! 

                                             

 Indeed, at precisely this moment the Jews, nearly en masse, began a full-scale boycott of Roman pottery (Red Slip Ware). Thus, the archaeological record seems to verify mass popular protest against Rome because of Varus' cruelty.  Following the massacre in Judaea, Varus returned to Antioch. 

 Roman officials weren't aware of the practice until they encountered it while fighting Carthage during the Punic Wars in the third century BCE.

For the next 500 years, the Romans "perfected crucifixion" until Constantine I abolished it in the fourth century CE., co-authors Francois Retief and Louise Cilliers, professors in the Department of English and Classical Culture at the University of the Free State in South Africa, wrote in the SAMJ report. However, given that crucifixion was seen as an extremely shameful way to die, Rome tended not to crucify its own citizens. Instead, slaves, disgraced soldiers, Christians, foreigners, and — in particular — political activists often lost their lives in this way, Retief and Cilliers reported.

Oh, the Jewish-Roman War had many reasons for starting and daring to fight Romans, and taxes were only one.  

In Rome, people condemned to crucifixion were scourged beforehand, with the exception of women, Roman senators and soldiers (unless they had deserted), Retief and Cilliers wrote. During scourging, a person was stripped naked, tied to a post, and then flogged across the back, buttocks and legs by Roman soldiers.

The next step varied with location. In Jerusalem, women would offer the condemned a pain-relieving drink, usually of wine and myrrh or incense. Then, the victim would be tied or nailed to the patibulum. After that, the patibulum was lifted and affixed to the upright post of the cross, and the feet would be tied or nailed to it. While the victim awaited death, soldiers would commonly divide up the victim's clothes among themselves. But death didn't always come quickly; it took anywhere from three hours to four days to expire, the professors wrote. Sometimes, the process was sped up by additional physical abuse from the Roman soldiers.  When the person died, family members could collect and bury the body, once they received permission from a Roman judge. Otherwise, the corpse was left on the cross, where predatory animals and birds would devour it.

The experienced and unassuming general Vespasian was given the task, by Nero, of crushing the rebellion in Judaea province. Vespasian's son Titus was appointed as second-in-command. Given four legions and assisted by forces of King Agrippa II, Vespasian invaded Galilee in 67.  They then occupied Judea for4 years before burning down Jerusalem and the Temple.             

Update: Many of the Jewish rebels were scattered or sold into slavery. Josephus claimed that 1,100,000 people were killed during the siege, 97,000 were captured and enslaved and many others fled to areas around the Mediterranean. A significant portion of the deaths was due to illnesses and hunger brought about by the Romans. "A pestilential destruction upon them, and soon afterward such a famine, as destroyed them more suddenly."                   

To summarize why the Jewish Rebellion had started, I find that Pompey had started the ball rolling by attacking and entering Judea and then occupying the Jewish state by 63 BCE. Herod the Great did his part in interference with Jewish life.   The Romans continued occupying Judah for over 100 years, there under different Generals and emperors by 70 CE and burning down the Temple and city.  The Roman occupiers made life miserable, meddling in their religion, and crucifying thousands of the young men with their power over the land.  The population could not take it and turned into groups of fighters fighting back in the best ways they could, even boycotting Roman pottery, winding up no doubt being crucified.   It was a worse situation than Afghanistan of today has faced with the Taliban and ISIS and had gone on for so long.  So the Jewish-Roman revolt started in 66 CE, and in 70 CE the Temple and city were burned down,  ending in 135 CE with the Jewish General Bar Kokhba's death on the battlefield after holding Jerusalem for 3 years.

  


Resource:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Jewish%E2%80%93Roman_War

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crucifixion_of_Jesus

https://www.livescience.com/65283-crucifixion-history.html#:~:text=In%204%20B.C.%2C%20the%20Roman,the%20Roman%2DJewish%20historian%20Josephus.

https://www.nationalgeographic.org/thisday/jul18/great-fire-rome/#:~:text=%EF%BB%BFThe%20popular%20myth%20that,slums%20that%20easily%20caught%20fire.&text=On%20July%2018%2C%2064%20CE%2C%20a%20fire%20started%20in%20the,now%20the%20capital%20of%20Italy.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Publius_Quinctilius_Varus

Wednesday, March 24, 2021

THE MASADA in Israel's History and Today

 Nadene Goldfoot                                                   

One mile West of the Dead Sea lies a lofty, isolated rock in Israel.  It's called Masada.  It's where all the IDF are sworn into the service of becoming the Israel Defense Force.  Why here?  Because of its history of Zealots being the last to stand for Israel.                                                                    

 Zealots were a Jewish political party in 2nd Temple Times founded in 6CE b Judah the Galilean and Zadok the high priest who demanded non-compliance with the Roman demand for a census which was their assessment of property on the grounds that this would constitute an acknowledgment of subjection.  Most likely they joined or already were Essenes who were living in caves.  They claimed that the sole ruler of the Jewish nation was G-d.  Their numbers were increasing.          

Their presence endangered another group, the Sicarii, a rebel group in the late 2nd Temple Period.  They were called after the dagger (sica-Latin) that they carried beneath their clothes.  They were against those desiring peace with Rome because of what they would be forced to lose in the process-their own religion, Judaism.  Menahem ben Jair and ELEAZAR BEN JAIR were known Sicarii.  

During the period immediately preceding the revolt against Rome in 66 CE, the Zealots won adherents from all social strata.  After the conflict with Rome had been sparked off, Menahem, son of Judah the Galilean, a member of the Sicarii, went to Jerusalem and appears to have claimed messianic status, and was slain by the captain of the Temple, Eleazar ben Hananiah.  His comrades, led by his kinsman, Eleazar Ben Jair, fled the city to Masada.   

                                                                 


It was originally a fortified area by the Judean king Alexander Yannai who was also the Cohen-the high priest,  who reigned 103-76 BCE, who was the son of John Hyrcanus, a Hashmonean of our Chanukah days,  and then served as a refuge for King Herod's family in 40 BCE when it was unsuccessfully besieged by Antigonus Mattathias.  Later, Herod built a palace there.                                   

Masada is on a massive plateau overlooking the Dead Sea. A cable car and a long, winding path climb up to the fortifications, built around 30 B.C.E.  Among the ruins are King Herod's Palace, which sprawls over 3 rock terraces, and a Roman-style bathhouse with mosaic floors.  Recognizing the defensive advantages of Masada, Herod built his complex there as a winter escape and haven from enemies, complete with castle, storerooms, cisterns and a foreboding wall.   

                                                                   

                      

It became a Roman garrison.  It was annihilated by the zealot,  Eleazar ben Jair in 66 CE and Masada was a Zealot fortress  Rome destroyed Jerusalem and Solomon's 2nd Temple in 70 CE.  Zealots had escaped to this high mountainous fortress with their wives and children who lived up there until the Romans came for them, ready to kill them all as they had done to Jerusalem.  The Zealots held out until 73.  What happened then was formidable.  The garrison of 960 Zealots and their wives and children under Eleazar, committed suicide in order to avoid capture by the Romans who were sure to do more savagery than just kill them with one blow.  They expected the worst; punishment for living.  Books have been written about it.  The one I read told of an older woman and child who was left alive, and the Romans let them live.                                              

Led by Flavius Silva, a legion of 8,000 Romans built camps surrounding the base, a siege wall, and a ramp on a slope of the Western side of the mountain made of earth and wooden supports. (Peter O'Toole on TV)

After several months of siege without success, the Romans built a tower on the ramp to try and take out the fortress’s wall. When it became clear that the Romans were going to take over Masada, on April 15, 73 A.D., on the instructions of Ben Yair, all but two women and five children, who hid in the cisterns and later told their stories, took their own lives rather than live as Roman slaves.                        

According to Josephus’s account in The Wars of the Jews: “They had died in the belief that they had left not a soul of them alive to fall into Roman hands; The Romans advanced to the assault … seeing none of the enemy but on all sides the awful solitude, and flames within and silence, they were at a loss to conjecture what had happened here encountering the mass of slain, instead of exulting as over enemies, they admired the nobility of their resolve.”

In later centuries, the site became a Roman post, a Byzantine chapel, and a Crusader stronghold.  A survey in 1955-6 uncovered the remains of Herod's palace as well as another palace dating from the Hasmonean Period. 

In 1963-5, extensive excavations were under Yigael Yadin--and the finds included scroll fragments and the site of the earliest known synagogue in Israel. 

Now an Israeli national park and a UNESCO World Heritage Site, the 840-acre complex holds well-preserved ruins attesting to the history of the ancient kingdom of Israel and the courage of its people in the face of a Roman siege.  The Masada Museum has archaeological exhibits and recreations of historical scenes for today's visitors.  

Resource:  

The New Standard Jewish Encyclopedia

https://jewishbubba.blogspot.com/2021/03/the-new-political-religious-judean.html

https://www.history.com/topics/ancient-middle-east/masada

Wednesday, March 10, 2021

The New Political-Religious Judean Defense Forces: The Zealots

 Nadene Goklfoot

 from ABC's TV movie, The Masada-Romans discovering the bodies of the Zealots.  

It so happened that Judah, the Galilean and Zadok, the high priest founded the political party of the Zealots in  the year 6 CE.  Zadok was a Sadducee and he demanded non-compliance with the Romans who were demanding that a census be taken in Judah which was for assessing the property of the Jews.  It would also acknowledge the Jews as subjected subjects of Rome.  

The Zealots took on religious ideals of their own and proclaimed G-d as the sole ruler of the Jewish nation.  They struggled with 2 powers;  that of foreign rulers such as Rome and their own Jewish people-the more wealthy who seemed to be obeying Roman law , taking them steps away from Judaism.

                                                   

The Zealots were oppressed terribly by the many governors of Judah, and increased their numbers.  One of their best leaders had been Eleazer ben Dinai who was executed by Felix Antonius, a governor (Procurator) in 73. He had been involved in border conflicts with the Ammonites and the northern Israelite Samaritans.  Felix had captured Eleazer and his men  in a ruse   (52-60) and as a prisoner, was sent to Rome where he died, possibly on one of their many crosses that lined the Apian Way.                

   Masada,  originally a place of refuge for Herod's family in 40 BCE when beseiged by Antigonus Mattathias.  Later, Herod built a palace on the top.  The Roman garrison was annihilated by Eleazar ben Jair in 66 CE and it became a Zealot fortress until 73 when the garrison of 960 under Eleazar died by their own hand.  

Masada was where Jews committed suicide rather than die by Roman hands. Masada was the last act of the Jewish war. The Jews became scattered into areas around the Mediterranean with many thousands being sold into slavery. Losses: Sicarii, 1,000; Roman, unknown..                               

The movie was based on the book, The Antagoists by Ernest Gann,, now on youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zz8CL7HiJhY.  

Zealots endangered the Sicarii rebels, named after a dagger they carried under their clothing.  They were murdering their political opponents who desired peace with Rome, knowing what price one had to pay for it that weakened their religious beliefs in one G-d.  The most well-known Sicarii was Menahem ben Jair and Eleazar ben Jair who held the Masada against the Romans until 73 CE.  

When the War against Rome started in 66, the Zealots were gaining members from all the different social strata.  After the conflict started,  Menahem, son of Judah the Galilean, a member of the Sicarii, went to Jerusalem and claimed messianic status but was slain by the captain of the Temple, Eleazar ben Hananiah.  His comrades, led by his kinsman, Eleazar ben Jair, fled the city to Masada.  Their omission from the revolutionary government came as a great disappointment.  The Roman successes in Galilee weakened the government and strengthened the position of the Zealots who terrorized their opponents, becoming terrorists.  They deposed the high priest and elected his successor by lot.   This caused the whole population to rebel against the terror and drove the Zealots under Eleazar ben Simon into the inner court of the Temple.  The Zealots in turn called for the support of the Iumeans who entered Jerusalem and massacred many of the citizens.  


Finally, the Zealots, under their leader, John of Gischala, regained control of Jerusalem and resumed their terrorism.  They were driven back into the Temple by Simon bar Giora, were in charge of the city when the final siege began in 70.                                                     

                         Zealots and Essenes : Quite different  

  After the terrible destruction of the city in 70, some of the zealots fled to the forest of Jardes where the Romans slaughtered them.  Others had fled to Egypt and Cyrene where they tried to stir up trouble but  were largely wiped out.  However, the North African revolt of 115-117 may have been caused by their descendants. Attempts have been made to identify the sect of the Dead Sea Scrolls with the Zealots.   

What would have happened had there been no Zealots or Sicarii and peace was made with Rome, instead?  What would have happened to the Jewish religion?  

Do you see the difference between Hamas terrorism of Gaza  and the Zealots and Sicarii terrorism?  Similarities?  

Resource:  

https://www.britannica.com/event/Siege-of-Masada